"It is dishonest the way that people suddenly think they've found guitars, and wear their guitar as a badge"
About this Quote
Waterman’s complaint isn’t really about guitars; it’s about status cosplay. The sting sits in “suddenly” and “badge”: a jab at people who don’t so much learn an instrument as adopt it like a logo, a quick costume change into “authentic musician” because the aesthetic is trending. Coming from a producer who helped industrialize pop’s hit-making machine, it’s an unusually blunt defense of craft. He’s drawing a line between making music and marketing identity, between work done in private and credibility purchased in public.
“Dishonest” is doing heavy lifting here. He’s not accusing anyone of lacking talent so much as skipping the part where devotion leaves marks: calluses, bad demos, years of being unglamorous. A guitar worn “as a badge” turns a tool into a medal, implying achievement without the grind that would justify it. That’s classic gatekeeping language, but it also reads as a protest against a culture that rewards the pose faster than the practice.
The context is late-20th-century pop’s constant churn: scenes rise and fall, genres get monetized, and the signifiers of “real music” (guitars, amps, band photos) become props even for people who could just as easily make tracks on a laptop. Waterman’s subtext: authenticity isn’t a look you put on, it’s the residue of doing the job when nobody’s watching.
“Dishonest” is doing heavy lifting here. He’s not accusing anyone of lacking talent so much as skipping the part where devotion leaves marks: calluses, bad demos, years of being unglamorous. A guitar worn “as a badge” turns a tool into a medal, implying achievement without the grind that would justify it. That’s classic gatekeeping language, but it also reads as a protest against a culture that rewards the pose faster than the practice.
The context is late-20th-century pop’s constant churn: scenes rise and fall, genres get monetized, and the signifiers of “real music” (guitars, amps, band photos) become props even for people who could just as easily make tracks on a laptop. Waterman’s subtext: authenticity isn’t a look you put on, it’s the residue of doing the job when nobody’s watching.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Pete
Add to List



