"It is during difficult times like this that the true American spirit reveals itself. I am not talking only of the response of local, state, and federal governments, although they will each play an extremely important role in this effort"
About this Quote
Crisis is the politician's favorite lighting: it makes ordinary governance look like character. Jo Bonner opens by invoking "difficult times" as a moral spotlight, then immediately frames the moment as a test that will reveal the "true American spirit". That's not neutral description; it's narrative control. In one sweep, hardship becomes proof of national virtue, and the audience is invited to audition for a role: resilient, unified, decent.
The phrase "true American spirit" does two kinds of work at once. It flatters the public (you already have what this moment requires) while quietly policing the boundaries of acceptable response. If there's a "true" spirit, there are also false versions: panic, anger, dissent, blame. The line doesn't attack those directly; it makes them feel un-American by omission.
Then comes the careful pivot: "I am not talking only of the response of local, state, and federal governments..". This is classic political triangulation. Bonner nods to institutions to signal competence and reassure anxious listeners that help is coming. But he also distances the emotional core of the response from government, implying that the real engine of recovery is communal grit, private charity, neighbors helping neighbors. That's a safer bet in American civic mythology and, for a conservative-leaning politician, a culturally familiar one: government matters, but it shouldn't be the hero of the story.
Contextually, this reads like remarks after a disaster or economic shock, when officials need solidarity fast and accountability can wait. The quote's intent is less to describe a plan than to preempt fragmentation by wrapping the moment in patriotic consensus.
The phrase "true American spirit" does two kinds of work at once. It flatters the public (you already have what this moment requires) while quietly policing the boundaries of acceptable response. If there's a "true" spirit, there are also false versions: panic, anger, dissent, blame. The line doesn't attack those directly; it makes them feel un-American by omission.
Then comes the careful pivot: "I am not talking only of the response of local, state, and federal governments..". This is classic political triangulation. Bonner nods to institutions to signal competence and reassure anxious listeners that help is coming. But he also distances the emotional core of the response from government, implying that the real engine of recovery is communal grit, private charity, neighbors helping neighbors. That's a safer bet in American civic mythology and, for a conservative-leaning politician, a culturally familiar one: government matters, but it shouldn't be the hero of the story.
Contextually, this reads like remarks after a disaster or economic shock, when officials need solidarity fast and accountability can wait. The quote's intent is less to describe a plan than to preempt fragmentation by wrapping the moment in patriotic consensus.
Quote Details
| Topic | Tough Times |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jo
Add to List


