"It is far better to foresee even without certainty than not to foresee at all"
About this Quote
Poincare is giving you permission to be wrong, as long as you’re wrong in the service of looking ahead. Coming from a mathematician who helped formalize chaos and lived at the border between neat equations and unruly reality, the line reads less like a fortune cookie and more like a practical ethic: prediction is not a parlor trick; it’s a way of organizing action under uncertainty.
The key move is the phrase “even without certainty.” In mathematics, certainty is the prized end state. In science and public life, it’s often a luxury. Poincare is quietly puncturing the vanity of waiting for perfect information. The subtext: refusing to forecast is not neutrality, it’s a choice to be surprised. “Not to foresee at all” is framed as the real failure, not the error bars inside a forecast.
Historically, this tracks with late-19th-century confidence in scientific progress colliding with the discovery that many systems (weather, three-body orbits, economies) are exquisitely sensitive to initial conditions. Poincare didn’t just study predictability; he mapped its limits. That gives the quote its bite: he isn’t celebrating naive certainty, he’s defending provisional models, educated guesses, and scenario thinking as honest tools.
It also works rhetorically because it flips the moral hierarchy. Accuracy isn’t the only virtue; preparedness is. Forecasting becomes a discipline of humility: you look ahead, admit you might be off, and act anyway. In an era addicted to “proof” before policy, Poincare’s challenge lands sharply.
The key move is the phrase “even without certainty.” In mathematics, certainty is the prized end state. In science and public life, it’s often a luxury. Poincare is quietly puncturing the vanity of waiting for perfect information. The subtext: refusing to forecast is not neutrality, it’s a choice to be surprised. “Not to foresee at all” is framed as the real failure, not the error bars inside a forecast.
Historically, this tracks with late-19th-century confidence in scientific progress colliding with the discovery that many systems (weather, three-body orbits, economies) are exquisitely sensitive to initial conditions. Poincare didn’t just study predictability; he mapped its limits. That gives the quote its bite: he isn’t celebrating naive certainty, he’s defending provisional models, educated guesses, and scenario thinking as honest tools.
It also works rhetorically because it flips the moral hierarchy. Accuracy isn’t the only virtue; preparedness is. Forecasting becomes a discipline of humility: you look ahead, admit you might be off, and act anyway. In an era addicted to “proof” before policy, Poincare’s challenge lands sharply.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Henri
Add to List
