"It is good to rub and polish our brain against that of others"
About this Quote
Montaigne makes thinking sound less like solitary genius and more like carpentry: brains get better by friction. The verb choice matters. “Rub and polish” isn’t polite conversation or genteel agreement; it’s contact, pressure, the minor abrasions that sand down vanity and sharpen judgment. He’s arguing that intellect is a material you work on, not a trophy you display. In an age still enthralled by inherited authority, this is a quietly radical move: knowledge doesn’t arrive sealed from on high, it gets forged in the mess of human exchange.
The subtext is a warning against the self-enclosed mind. Montaigne knew how easily we mistake inner monologue for truth, especially when we’re well-read and alone. Other people are the necessary irritant that exposes our blind spots, the way a contrary friend can puncture a beautifully reasoned idea by asking one inconvenient question. “Polish” also implies refinement, not just correction: conversation doesn’t only catch errors; it improves style, nuance, proportion.
Context sharpens the intent. Writing in the turbulent French Renaissance, amid religious wars and collapsing certainties, Montaigne developed skepticism as a survival skill. His Essays are built from encounters-with texts, with travelers, with neighbors, with himself in argument. The line endorses a humane epistemology: you don’t defeat others’ minds to prove yours; you test yours against theirs to make it usable. It’s a blueprint for public life, too. A society that can’t tolerate the friction of disagreement doesn’t stay polished; it just stays brittle.
The subtext is a warning against the self-enclosed mind. Montaigne knew how easily we mistake inner monologue for truth, especially when we’re well-read and alone. Other people are the necessary irritant that exposes our blind spots, the way a contrary friend can puncture a beautifully reasoned idea by asking one inconvenient question. “Polish” also implies refinement, not just correction: conversation doesn’t only catch errors; it improves style, nuance, proportion.
Context sharpens the intent. Writing in the turbulent French Renaissance, amid religious wars and collapsing certainties, Montaigne developed skepticism as a survival skill. His Essays are built from encounters-with texts, with travelers, with neighbors, with himself in argument. The line endorses a humane epistemology: you don’t defeat others’ minds to prove yours; you test yours against theirs to make it usable. It’s a blueprint for public life, too. A society that can’t tolerate the friction of disagreement doesn’t stay polished; it just stays brittle.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Michel
Add to List







