"It is in revolutionary periods that the culmination of previous trends and the beginning of new ones appear"
About this Quote
Revolutions, C. L. R. James suggests, don’t arrive as lightning bolts; they arrive as receipts. The line is doing two things at once: stripping rebellion of its romantic “year zero” mythology while also defending its urgency. “Culmination of previous trends” is a historian’s phrase with a polemic edge: the streets don’t suddenly invent new demands, they force into visibility what has been accumulating in factories, plantations, parliaments, and private life. The pressure was already there; the rupture is when it becomes impossible to ignore.
James wrote as a Marxist-inflected journalist and an anti-colonial thinker, best known for The Black Jacobins and his account of the Haitian Revolution. That background matters. He’s arguing against the comfortable view that upheaval is irrational, criminal, or merely spontaneous. In James’s framing, revolution is a diagnostic moment: it reveals the underlying structure of a society by showing what breaks first, who moves together, and what stories can no longer hold.
The second half of the sentence is the real wager. Revolutionary periods are not just endings; they’re portals. “The beginning of new ones” refuses nostalgia and warns against seeing revolt as pure negation. New institutions, new language, new solidarities start forming inside the chaos, often imperfectly, often before anyone has a plan. The subtext is strategic: if revolutions are both climax and seedbed, then organizers and writers have a responsibility to read the past accurately and to shape the future deliberately, because history, in these moments, is suddenly editable.
James wrote as a Marxist-inflected journalist and an anti-colonial thinker, best known for The Black Jacobins and his account of the Haitian Revolution. That background matters. He’s arguing against the comfortable view that upheaval is irrational, criminal, or merely spontaneous. In James’s framing, revolution is a diagnostic moment: it reveals the underlying structure of a society by showing what breaks first, who moves together, and what stories can no longer hold.
The second half of the sentence is the real wager. Revolutionary periods are not just endings; they’re portals. “The beginning of new ones” refuses nostalgia and warns against seeing revolt as pure negation. New institutions, new language, new solidarities start forming inside the chaos, often imperfectly, often before anyone has a plan. The subtext is strategic: if revolutions are both climax and seedbed, then organizers and writers have a responsibility to read the past accurately and to shape the future deliberately, because history, in these moments, is suddenly editable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|
More Quotes by L. R. James
Add to List


