"It is my nature to thin where others read"
About this Quote
A sly brag disguised as confession, Sydenham's line turns intellectual independence into temperament: not a method he chose, but a nature he can't help. The misspelling-like sting of "thin" (almost certainly "think") matters because it frames his point as friction. Where others "read" - absorb authority, repeat learned opinion, defer to texts - he thinks, cuts, tests. It's a miniature manifesto against bookish medicine.
Sydenham practiced in an era when Galen still haunted the clinic. Seventeenth-century physicians were trained to win arguments with citations, not necessarily to watch bodies with patience. Sydenham's reputation, later cemented as the "English Hippocrates", rested on the opposite impulse: careful bedside observation, attention to symptoms over speculation, and a pragmatic tolerance for not knowing the underlying "causes" as long as you could describe the disease faithfully and treat it effectively. In that context, "where others read" isn't an innocent contrast; it's a jab at scholasticism and the status economy of learned medicine.
The subtext is political as much as epistemic. "Others" are a class - credentialed men whose power comes from texts and Latin. Sydenham casts himself as the clinician who answers to the patient and to evidence. The sentence works because it's compact, categorical, and slightly contemptuous: reading is passive and social; thinking is active and solitary. It flatters the modern ideal of science as skepticism with a stethoscope, while warning that information, even correct information, can become a substitute for judgment.
Sydenham practiced in an era when Galen still haunted the clinic. Seventeenth-century physicians were trained to win arguments with citations, not necessarily to watch bodies with patience. Sydenham's reputation, later cemented as the "English Hippocrates", rested on the opposite impulse: careful bedside observation, attention to symptoms over speculation, and a pragmatic tolerance for not knowing the underlying "causes" as long as you could describe the disease faithfully and treat it effectively. In that context, "where others read" isn't an innocent contrast; it's a jab at scholasticism and the status economy of learned medicine.
The subtext is political as much as epistemic. "Others" are a class - credentialed men whose power comes from texts and Latin. Sydenham casts himself as the clinician who answers to the patient and to evidence. The sentence works because it's compact, categorical, and slightly contemptuous: reading is passive and social; thinking is active and solitary. It flatters the modern ideal of science as skepticism with a stethoscope, while warning that information, even correct information, can become a substitute for judgment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List
