"It is not 'progressive' to try to resolve problems by eliminating a human life"
About this Quote
“It is not ‘progressive’ to try to resolve problems by eliminating a human life” is Pope Francis doing two things at once: reclaiming a political label and tightening the moral frame until there’s nowhere comfortable to stand. By putting “progressive” in quotes, he signals suspicion toward a word that often functions as a moral halo in modern debate. The line isn’t aimed only at policy; it’s aimed at language itself, at the way euphemism and branding can launder hard choices into something that sounds enlightened.
The intent is sharply pastoral and sharply strategic. Francis speaks in an era when social progress is commonly equated with expanded autonomy, especially around abortion and end-of-life decisions. He refuses that equation, insisting that the benchmark for a humane society isn’t how efficiently it manages suffering, poverty, disability, or inconvenience, but whether it can face those problems without defining certain people as disposable.
Subtext: if your solution requires someone to disappear, you haven’t solved a problem; you’ve moved it off the ledger. The sentence also carries his broader critique of a “throwaway culture,” where the weak are treated as obstacles to be optimized away. It’s a line meant to puncture the self-congratulation that can surround “compassionate” justifications for lethal outcomes.
Context matters: Francis is not offering a technical argument about law or medicine; he’s asserting a moral boundary in a culture war over who gets counted as fully human. The rhetoric is simple on purpose. It’s designed to travel, to be repeated, to force any listener who prizes progress to answer a harder question: progress for whom, and at what cost?
The intent is sharply pastoral and sharply strategic. Francis speaks in an era when social progress is commonly equated with expanded autonomy, especially around abortion and end-of-life decisions. He refuses that equation, insisting that the benchmark for a humane society isn’t how efficiently it manages suffering, poverty, disability, or inconvenience, but whether it can face those problems without defining certain people as disposable.
Subtext: if your solution requires someone to disappear, you haven’t solved a problem; you’ve moved it off the ledger. The sentence also carries his broader critique of a “throwaway culture,” where the weak are treated as obstacles to be optimized away. It’s a line meant to puncture the self-congratulation that can surround “compassionate” justifications for lethal outcomes.
Context matters: Francis is not offering a technical argument about law or medicine; he’s asserting a moral boundary in a culture war over who gets counted as fully human. The rhetoric is simple on purpose. It’s designed to travel, to be repeated, to force any listener who prizes progress to answer a harder question: progress for whom, and at what cost?
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Pope
Add to List





