"It is not so much the example of others we imitate as the reflection of ourselves in their eyes and the echo of ourselves in their words"
About this Quote
Imitation, Hoffer suggests, is less about admiration than self-recognition: we don’t borrow other people’s lives so much as we chase the version of ourselves they seem to confirm. The line has the clean, unsettling precision Hoffer often favored as a self-taught moral psychologist of the crowd. It quietly demotes the heroic story we tell about influence (I’m inspired by greatness) and replaces it with a more compromised engine: validation.
The intent is diagnostic. Hoffer isn’t praising empathy or learning; he’s dissecting the narcissism hiding inside “role models.” The “reflection” and “echo” metaphors do heavy work: they imply a closed circuit, a feedback loop where the other person becomes a mirror or a microphone. Subtext: the admired figure is frequently incidental; what matters is the audience they provide. Even their words function less as instruction than as permission slips for what we already want to be.
Context matters here. Writing in the shadow of mass movements, propaganda, and the mid-century anxieties of belonging, Hoffer was preoccupied with how identity gets outsourced to crowds, leaders, and causes. This sentence slots neatly into that project: it frames conformity and fandom not as simple copying, but as a longing to be seen, stabilized, and amplified. People “imitate” what makes them feel coherent.
The quote still lands because it anticipates modern social life: the self curated through likes, shares, and algorithmic affirmation. We mimic the people who reflect us back as desirable, righteous, or interesting, then call it taste. Hoffer’s sting is that influence isn’t a one-way transmission of excellence; it’s a negotiation for recognition.
The intent is diagnostic. Hoffer isn’t praising empathy or learning; he’s dissecting the narcissism hiding inside “role models.” The “reflection” and “echo” metaphors do heavy work: they imply a closed circuit, a feedback loop where the other person becomes a mirror or a microphone. Subtext: the admired figure is frequently incidental; what matters is the audience they provide. Even their words function less as instruction than as permission slips for what we already want to be.
Context matters here. Writing in the shadow of mass movements, propaganda, and the mid-century anxieties of belonging, Hoffer was preoccupied with how identity gets outsourced to crowds, leaders, and causes. This sentence slots neatly into that project: it frames conformity and fandom not as simple copying, but as a longing to be seen, stabilized, and amplified. People “imitate” what makes them feel coherent.
The quote still lands because it anticipates modern social life: the self curated through likes, shares, and algorithmic affirmation. We mimic the people who reflect us back as desirable, righteous, or interesting, then call it taste. Hoffer’s sting is that influence isn’t a one-way transmission of excellence; it’s a negotiation for recognition.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List



