"It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride, monseigneur"
About this Quote
Parker, a politician-novelist operating in an age obsessed with empire, class, and public reputation, knows where bodies are buried: in the space between how people see themselves and how they are seen. A broken heart can be mourned. Broken pride demands either restoration or revenge. The sentence is built like a diagnosis, coolly corrective: “not X … but Y.” That structure performs authority, as if the speaker is stripping away a comforting story and replacing it with a darker mechanism.
The subtext is a warning to anyone with power: you can survive other people’s sadness; you may not survive their humiliation. It’s also a small act of realism about masculinity and public life, where grief gets coded as weakness but wounded pride can masquerade as principle. In Parker’s world, pride doesn’t just sit in the psyche; it animates duels, rebellions, resignations, vendettas. The line works because it refuses the tidy tragedy of romance and points to the messier engine of history: injured dignity looking for a stage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Heartbreak |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: The Battle of the Strong (Gilbert Parker, 1898)
Evidence: “What did you think was left for a woman, for a Chantavoine? It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride, monseigneur.” (Chapter XLIII). The quote appears in Gilbert Parker's novel The Battle of the Strong: A Romance of Two Kingdoms, first published in 1898. In the text, the line is spoken by the character Grandjon-Larisse to Philip d'Avranche, so it is not a standalone aphorism originally published by itself. In the Project Gutenberg transcription, the line appears at Chapter XLIII. The same text is echoed again immediately afterward in Chapter XLIV in slightly shortened form: “It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride.” Evidence from bibliographic records indicates the novel was first issued in 1898, with some copies showing a 1897 copyright notice and 1898 title-page publication. I did not verify an original print page number from a scanned first edition in this search, but the chapter location is verified from the primary text. The wording with “monseigneur” is part of the original novel dialogue. Other candidates (1) The Complete Works of Gilbert Parker (Gilbert Parker)95.0% Gilbert Parker. last, by a dexterous feint, he beat aside Philip's guard and drove the sword through his right breast... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Parker, Gilbert. (2026, March 11). It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride, monseigneur. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-is-not-the-broken-heart-that-kills-but-broken-142525/
Chicago Style
Parker, Gilbert. "It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride, monseigneur." FixQuotes. March 11, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-is-not-the-broken-heart-that-kills-but-broken-142525/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"It is not the broken heart that kills, but broken pride, monseigneur." FixQuotes, 11 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/it-is-not-the-broken-heart-that-kills-but-broken-142525/. Accessed 13 Mar. 2026.










