"It is not the intelligent woman v. the ignorant woman; nor the white woman v. the black, the brown, and the red, it is not even the cause of woman v. man. Nay, tis woman's strongest vindication for speaking that the world needs to hear her voice"
About this Quote
Cooper cuts against the cheap thrill of a gender “battle” and replaces it with something more unsettling: a demand that women be heard not as a special interest group, but as a necessary instrument of truth. The opening litany of false matchups - intelligent versus ignorant, white versus “black, the brown, and the red,” woman versus man - reads like a preemptive strike against the favorite distractions of power. Split the constituency, turn liberation into a competition for proximity to respectability, and you never have to confront the structure that produces “ignorance” or racial hierarchy in the first place.
Her diction matters. “Nay, tis” has the cadence of the pulpit and the parlor, a deliberate borrowing of respectable register to smuggle radical content into spaces that policed Black women’s speech. “Vindication” is courtroom language: she’s arguing a case before a society that treats women’s public voice as an offense requiring justification. But the twist is that the justification isn’t individual achievement or moral superiority; it’s collective need. The “world” is indicted as incomplete, poorly informed, even spiritually malnourished without women’s testimony.
Placed in Cooper’s era - post-Reconstruction retrenchment, the tightening of Jim Crow, a suffrage movement often willing to bargain with racism - the line also reads as a rebuke to single-axis feminism before we had that phrase. She refuses to choose between race and gender, and she refuses to let “woman” mean “white woman.” The subtext is blunt: democracy can’t be built by muting the people who see its failures most clearly.
Her diction matters. “Nay, tis” has the cadence of the pulpit and the parlor, a deliberate borrowing of respectable register to smuggle radical content into spaces that policed Black women’s speech. “Vindication” is courtroom language: she’s arguing a case before a society that treats women’s public voice as an offense requiring justification. But the twist is that the justification isn’t individual achievement or moral superiority; it’s collective need. The “world” is indicted as incomplete, poorly informed, even spiritually malnourished without women’s testimony.
Placed in Cooper’s era - post-Reconstruction retrenchment, the tightening of Jim Crow, a suffrage movement often willing to bargain with racism - the line also reads as a rebuke to single-axis feminism before we had that phrase. She refuses to choose between race and gender, and she refuses to let “woman” mean “white woman.” The subtext is blunt: democracy can’t be built by muting the people who see its failures most clearly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Anna Julia Cooper, A Voice from the South: By a Black Woman of the South, 1892 — contains passage beginning "'Tis woman's strongest vindication for speaking that the world needs to hear her voice." |
More Quotes by Anna
Add to List
