"It is only prudent never to place complete confidence in that by which we have even once been deceived"
About this Quote
Prudence, for Descartes, is less a moral virtue than a survival tactic for the mind. The line has the crisp chill of someone who has watched certainty collapse and decided that “trust” is a methodological problem. One deception is enough to poison the whole well; the rational response is not mild caution but a systematic downgrade of confidence.
That severity makes sense in context. Descartes is writing in the wake of scholastic authority wobbling, religious wars fracturing Europe, and a new science demanding proofs rather than inherited assurances. In the Meditations, his project is radical: clear the slate of beliefs that could be false, then rebuild knowledge on foundations that cannot be shaken. This sentence is the social contract of doubt: if the senses, tradition, or even your own reasoning have misled you once, you treat them like a witness caught lying. They might still be useful, but they no longer get the benefit of the doubt.
The subtext is a quiet indictment of intellectual complacency. Descartes isn’t warning against gullibility in the everyday sense; he’s arguing that ordinary confidence is epistemic negligence. The phrasing “even once” is key: it rejects the comforting idea that errors are rare exceptions. In an era of optical illusions, unreliable testimony, and theological polemics, “once” is proof of a structural vulnerability.
It works because it turns skepticism into discipline, not mood. Doubt becomes a tool with an ethic: trust must be earned by what can withstand scrutiny, not granted by habit.
That severity makes sense in context. Descartes is writing in the wake of scholastic authority wobbling, religious wars fracturing Europe, and a new science demanding proofs rather than inherited assurances. In the Meditations, his project is radical: clear the slate of beliefs that could be false, then rebuild knowledge on foundations that cannot be shaken. This sentence is the social contract of doubt: if the senses, tradition, or even your own reasoning have misled you once, you treat them like a witness caught lying. They might still be useful, but they no longer get the benefit of the doubt.
The subtext is a quiet indictment of intellectual complacency. Descartes isn’t warning against gullibility in the everyday sense; he’s arguing that ordinary confidence is epistemic negligence. The phrasing “even once” is key: it rejects the comforting idea that errors are rare exceptions. In an era of optical illusions, unreliable testimony, and theological polemics, “once” is proof of a structural vulnerability.
It works because it turns skepticism into discipline, not mood. Doubt becomes a tool with an ethic: trust must be earned by what can withstand scrutiny, not granted by habit.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Rene
Add to List
