"It is pretty hard to tell what does bring happiness; poverty and wealth have both failed"
About this Quote
Hubbard’s joke lands because it refuses the oldest moral bargain in American life: that the right economic condition will finally make you feel okay. By pairing poverty and wealth as equal disappointments, he doesn’t “both-sides” inequality so much as puncture the superstition that money is a clean narrative arc. The line is built like a deadpan lab report: we’ve run the experiment twice, under opposite conditions, and the results are still inconclusive. That faux objectivity is the wit.
The specific intent is corrective, not consoling. Hubbard is warning his readers off the idea that happiness is a purchase, a promotion, a change of ZIP code. He’s also taking a jab at the period’s booming self-help and success literature, which sold prosperity as a moral credential and misery as a personal failure. If wealth doesn’t guarantee happiness, then the smugness of the rich and the shame of the poor both look suspect.
The subtext is darker than the punchline admits: if neither scarcity nor abundance reliably “brings happiness,” then the chase becomes endless, and people become easy prey for marketers, politicians, and motivational hucksters who promise the missing ingredient. Hubbard wrote in an America industrializing fast, stratifying faster, and flirting with mass consumerism. His journalism-era one-liner catches a society discovering that modern life can raise living standards while lowering the spirit’s sense of arrival. The cynicism is brisk, but it’s also oddly humane: it frees you from thinking your bank balance is a verdict on your inner life.
The specific intent is corrective, not consoling. Hubbard is warning his readers off the idea that happiness is a purchase, a promotion, a change of ZIP code. He’s also taking a jab at the period’s booming self-help and success literature, which sold prosperity as a moral credential and misery as a personal failure. If wealth doesn’t guarantee happiness, then the smugness of the rich and the shame of the poor both look suspect.
The subtext is darker than the punchline admits: if neither scarcity nor abundance reliably “brings happiness,” then the chase becomes endless, and people become easy prey for marketers, politicians, and motivational hucksters who promise the missing ingredient. Hubbard wrote in an America industrializing fast, stratifying faster, and flirting with mass consumerism. His journalism-era one-liner catches a society discovering that modern life can raise living standards while lowering the spirit’s sense of arrival. The cynicism is brisk, but it’s also oddly humane: it frees you from thinking your bank balance is a verdict on your inner life.
Quote Details
| Topic | Happiness |
|---|
More Quotes by Kin
Add to List
