"It is right to hate sin, but not to hate the sinner"
About this Quote
A clean moral scalpel: cut out the wrongdoing without amputating the human being. Guareschi, a journalist with a satirist's instinct for how quickly righteousness curdles into cruelty, frames the line as a kind of ethical safety catch. The phrase feels pious at first glance, but its real target is social and political: the way communities use "sin" as an excuse to enjoy hating people.
The construction matters. "Right" grants moral permission to feel anger, even revulsion. He's not selling soft relativism. Then the sentence pivots on "but", and the pivot is the point: hatred, once aimed at a person, becomes lazy, self-flattering, and contagious. You stop seeing specifics; you start seeing types. The sinner becomes a symbol, and the hate becomes a hobby.
In mid-century Italy - riven by Catholic moral authority, postwar trauma, and the bruising ideological fight between Christian Democrats and Communists - this distinction isn't abstract. It's an argument against the politics of moral contamination, where opponents aren't wrong, they're rotten. Guareschi knew propaganda thrives on turning sins into identities: adulterer, communist, heretic, traitor. Once labeled, a person can be dismissed, punished, or dehumanized with a clean conscience.
Subtext: the hardest discipline isn't condemning evil, it's refusing the emotional payoff of contempt. The line asks for a stricter kind of judgment - one that keeps accountability intact while denying hatred its favorite alibi: "They deserve it."
The construction matters. "Right" grants moral permission to feel anger, even revulsion. He's not selling soft relativism. Then the sentence pivots on "but", and the pivot is the point: hatred, once aimed at a person, becomes lazy, self-flattering, and contagious. You stop seeing specifics; you start seeing types. The sinner becomes a symbol, and the hate becomes a hobby.
In mid-century Italy - riven by Catholic moral authority, postwar trauma, and the bruising ideological fight between Christian Democrats and Communists - this distinction isn't abstract. It's an argument against the politics of moral contamination, where opponents aren't wrong, they're rotten. Guareschi knew propaganda thrives on turning sins into identities: adulterer, communist, heretic, traitor. Once labeled, a person can be dismissed, punished, or dehumanized with a clean conscience.
Subtext: the hardest discipline isn't condemning evil, it's refusing the emotional payoff of contempt. The line asks for a stricter kind of judgment - one that keeps accountability intact while denying hatred its favorite alibi: "They deserve it."
Quote Details
| Topic | Forgiveness |
|---|
More Quotes by Giovanni
Add to List
