"It is sound judgment to hope that in the not too distant future we shall be competent to understand so simple a thing as a star"
About this Quote
Eddington calls a star "so simple" with the kind of dry provocation only a great scientist can get away with. The line is a wink and a warning: the object that looks like a tidy pinprick in the sky is, in 1920s terms, a furnace of physics that was still refusing to fully add up. By shrinking the star into a "simple thing", he exposes how un-simple our understanding remains, turning humility into a rhetorical instrument rather than a pious gesture.
The intent is aspirational, but not triumphalist. "Sound judgment" matters here: Eddington is staking out a middle ground between naive faith in progress and fashionable despair about the limits of knowledge. He's arguing that optimism can be rational, even disciplined. The phrasing "hope that... we shall be competent" shifts the focus from discovering facts to becoming the kind of thinkers who can hold them. Competence is ethical as much as technical: it implies mathematical tools, better measurements, and the intellectual temperament to accept counterintuitive truths.
Context sharpens the edge. Eddington was a chief evangelist for Einstein in the English-speaking world and a central figure in early stellar astrophysics (including the debate over what powers stars). In that moment, "understanding a star" meant binding together relativity, quantum ideas, spectroscopy, and the emerging picture of stellar structure. The subtext is a quiet rebuke to anyone treating science as a catalogue of settled answers. Even the most familiar lights overhead are admissions of how much work remains.
The intent is aspirational, but not triumphalist. "Sound judgment" matters here: Eddington is staking out a middle ground between naive faith in progress and fashionable despair about the limits of knowledge. He's arguing that optimism can be rational, even disciplined. The phrasing "hope that... we shall be competent" shifts the focus from discovering facts to becoming the kind of thinkers who can hold them. Competence is ethical as much as technical: it implies mathematical tools, better measurements, and the intellectual temperament to accept counterintuitive truths.
Context sharpens the edge. Eddington was a chief evangelist for Einstein in the English-speaking world and a central figure in early stellar astrophysics (including the debate over what powers stars). In that moment, "understanding a star" meant binding together relativity, quantum ideas, spectroscopy, and the emerging picture of stellar structure. The subtext is a quiet rebuke to anyone treating science as a catalogue of settled answers. Even the most familiar lights overhead are admissions of how much work remains.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List










