"It is the greatest mistake to think that man is always one and the same. A man is never the same for long. He is continually changing. He seldom remains the same even for half an hour"
About this Quote
Gurdjieff takes a common consolation - that there is a stable "real me" under the noise - and flips it into an accusation. The line reads like a calm observation about human complexity, but its real intent is disciplinary: if you believe you are one coherent self, you are asleep. The blunt pacing ("never... for long", "even for half an hour") isn’t poetry so much as a verbal stress test, designed to make the listener catch themselves mid-sentence: Which "I" is talking right now?
The subtext is that inconsistency isn’t just moodiness; it’s evidence of fragmentation. In Gurdjieff’s worldview, most people are a crowd of competing impulses and borrowed opinions, taking turns at the wheel while the ego insists on a single driver. That’s why the quote is framed as "the greatest mistake" rather than a gentle insight. He’s targeting self-congratulating sincerity: the modern habit of treating whatever you feel at the moment as your authentic essence.
Context matters. Gurdjieff’s teaching emerged from early 20th-century Europe’s fascination with psychology, mysticism, and self-making, but he’s allergic to the era’s comforting idea of self-improvement through positive thinking. His "Fourth Way" demanded attention, friction, and conscious effort - not to express oneself, but to assemble oneself. The rhetoric works because it’s both relatable (we all recognize our internal contradictions) and destabilizing: if you’re always changing, then identity becomes a task, not a possession. That’s an unnerving proposition in any era, and it lands especially hard in a culture built on the performance of consistency.
The subtext is that inconsistency isn’t just moodiness; it’s evidence of fragmentation. In Gurdjieff’s worldview, most people are a crowd of competing impulses and borrowed opinions, taking turns at the wheel while the ego insists on a single driver. That’s why the quote is framed as "the greatest mistake" rather than a gentle insight. He’s targeting self-congratulating sincerity: the modern habit of treating whatever you feel at the moment as your authentic essence.
Context matters. Gurdjieff’s teaching emerged from early 20th-century Europe’s fascination with psychology, mysticism, and self-making, but he’s allergic to the era’s comforting idea of self-improvement through positive thinking. His "Fourth Way" demanded attention, friction, and conscious effort - not to express oneself, but to assemble oneself. The rhetoric works because it’s both relatable (we all recognize our internal contradictions) and destabilizing: if you’re always changing, then identity becomes a task, not a possession. That’s an unnerving proposition in any era, and it lands especially hard in a culture built on the performance of consistency.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by I. Gurdjieff
Add to List










