"It is thus necessary to examine all things according to their essence, to infer from every species such true and well established propositions as may assist us in the solution of metaphysical problems"
About this Quote
A medieval rabbi telling you to “examine all things according to their essence” is not offering misty contemplation; he’s laying down a discipline. Maimonides writes in a world where “metaphysics” is both the loftiest ambition and the easiest place to smuggle in comforting nonsense. His intent is almost procedural: look past surface features, classify carefully (“every species”), and only then allow yourself propositions that are “true and well established.” The phrase reads like a gatekeeping mechanism, and that’s the point. He wants metaphysics to be earned.
The subtext is a warning shot at two audiences at once. To religious literalists, he’s implying that reading sacred texts without philosophical rigor invites error; revelation doesn’t exempt you from good method. To speculative philosophers drunk on abstraction, he’s insisting that metaphysical claims must be tethered to what can be responsibly inferred from the world’s structure. “Essence” here isn’t a vibe; it’s an Aristotelian tool for distinguishing what a thing is from what merely happens to it.
Context matters: Maimonides is working in the wake of Aristotle’s re-entry into the intellectual bloodstream via Islamic philosophy, and under the pressure of harmonizing rational inquiry with Jewish theology. His strategy is not to shrink metaphysics but to civilize it. The sentence performs what it preaches: orderly, hierarchical, suspicious of improvisation. It’s an argument for intellectual humility disguised as confidence - you may pursue the highest questions, but only on the condition that you accept constraints.
The subtext is a warning shot at two audiences at once. To religious literalists, he’s implying that reading sacred texts without philosophical rigor invites error; revelation doesn’t exempt you from good method. To speculative philosophers drunk on abstraction, he’s insisting that metaphysical claims must be tethered to what can be responsibly inferred from the world’s structure. “Essence” here isn’t a vibe; it’s an Aristotelian tool for distinguishing what a thing is from what merely happens to it.
Context matters: Maimonides is working in the wake of Aristotle’s re-entry into the intellectual bloodstream via Islamic philosophy, and under the pressure of harmonizing rational inquiry with Jewish theology. His strategy is not to shrink metaphysics but to civilize it. The sentence performs what it preaches: orderly, hierarchical, suspicious of improvisation. It’s an argument for intellectual humility disguised as confidence - you may pursue the highest questions, but only on the condition that you accept constraints.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Maimonides
Add to List
