"It is time for dead languages to be quiet"
About this Quote
Barney’s line lands like a salon door clicking shut: polite, decisive, and just scandalous enough to make the room lean in. “It is time for dead languages to be quiet” isn’t an anti-intellectual tantrum; it’s a targeted jab at cultural gatekeeping, delivered by a writer who spent her life building alternative institutions of taste. Barney, an American expatriate in Paris and a magnet for modernist talent, understood how Latin and Greek could function less as tools than as talismans - symbols of who gets to speak with authority.
The phrasing does sly work. “Dead languages” are anthropomorphized, told to “be quiet,” as if they’ve been talking over the living. Barney isn’t denying their historical value; she’s insisting they stop monopolizing the conversation. The imperative “It is time” gives the sentence the force of an overdue correction, the kind that arrives after centuries of curricula treating the classics as a moral credential rather than one tradition among many.
Context matters: early 20th-century literary modernism was a revolt against inherited forms, and women in particular were expected to earn entry by mastering the old codes. Barney flips that demand. Her subtext is feminist and cosmopolitan: the future of art and thought doesn’t need to be ventriloquized through a prestige dialect. Let the living languages, the living bodies, the living desires speak without translation. In one clean sentence, she demotes the museum to its proper role and reclaims the present as a legitimate source of genius.
The phrasing does sly work. “Dead languages” are anthropomorphized, told to “be quiet,” as if they’ve been talking over the living. Barney isn’t denying their historical value; she’s insisting they stop monopolizing the conversation. The imperative “It is time” gives the sentence the force of an overdue correction, the kind that arrives after centuries of curricula treating the classics as a moral credential rather than one tradition among many.
Context matters: early 20th-century literary modernism was a revolt against inherited forms, and women in particular were expected to earn entry by mastering the old codes. Barney flips that demand. Her subtext is feminist and cosmopolitan: the future of art and thought doesn’t need to be ventriloquized through a prestige dialect. Let the living languages, the living bodies, the living desires speak without translation. In one clean sentence, she demotes the museum to its proper role and reclaims the present as a legitimate source of genius.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Natalie
Add to List







