"It is too difficult to think nobly when one thinks only of earning a living"
About this Quote
Austere and slightly accusatory, Rousseau’s line is a moral trap disguised as a plain observation: if your mind is consumed by rent, you’re structurally blocked from “noble” thought. The genius is the phrasing “too difficult,” which sidesteps blaming individual character while still indicting a social order. He’s not saying the poor are ignoble; he’s saying a society that keeps people in survival mode robs them of the conditions for virtue. That’s a political charge wearing the mask of psychology.
The subtext is Rousseau’s signature suspicion of modern life: civilization doesn’t just add comforts, it manufactures dependencies. “Earning a living” sounds neutral, even wholesome, but in his mouth it becomes a narrowing of human possibility. Nobility here isn’t aristocratic manners; it’s moral imagination, public-mindedness, the capacity to reason beyond immediate appetite. If you’re forced into constant calculation, you’ll start to treat everything - time, relationships, conscience - as transactional. The market becomes not a tool but a worldview.
Context matters: Rousseau writes in an 18th-century Europe where inequality is justified as natural and productive, and where emergent commercial society is reshaping identity. He’s laying groundwork for a radical claim that will echo into modern politics: freedom isn’t just the absence of chains; it’s the presence of slack - time, security, and dignity enough to think past tomorrow. The sting is that he makes “nobility” a social achievement, not a private virtue.
The subtext is Rousseau’s signature suspicion of modern life: civilization doesn’t just add comforts, it manufactures dependencies. “Earning a living” sounds neutral, even wholesome, but in his mouth it becomes a narrowing of human possibility. Nobility here isn’t aristocratic manners; it’s moral imagination, public-mindedness, the capacity to reason beyond immediate appetite. If you’re forced into constant calculation, you’ll start to treat everything - time, relationships, conscience - as transactional. The market becomes not a tool but a worldview.
Context matters: Rousseau writes in an 18th-century Europe where inequality is justified as natural and productive, and where emergent commercial society is reshaping identity. He’s laying groundwork for a radical claim that will echo into modern politics: freedom isn’t just the absence of chains; it’s the presence of slack - time, security, and dignity enough to think past tomorrow. The sting is that he makes “nobility” a social achievement, not a private virtue.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work Ethic |
|---|---|
| Source | Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Emile, or On Education (1762). Line commonly attributed to Emile, usually translated as: "It is too difficult to think nobly when one thinks only of earning a living." |
More Quotes by Jean-Jacques
Add to List
