"It is vain to say human beings ought to be satisfied with tranquility; they must have action; and they will make it if they cannot find it"
About this Quote
Bronte lands a quiet Victorian gut-punch: the problem with preaching serenity isn’t that it’s wrong, it’s that it’s useless. “Vain” is the tell - not morally misguided, but socially delusional. The line doesn’t flatter human nature; it diagnoses it. People don’t simply desire action, they require it, and when a culture offers only “tranquility” as a feminine virtue or a respectable adult mood, that pressure doesn’t disappear. It reroutes.
The subtext is a rebuke to a whole etiquette of containment. In Bronte’s world, tranquility is often code for obedience: for women, especially, a decorative calm that keeps them in their place. By insisting “they will make it if they cannot find it,” she exposes how repression manufactures its own disturbances. If life won’t provide purpose, ambition, romance, danger, meaningful work - humans will improvise substitutes: dramas, scandals, self-sabotage, crusades. Action becomes not just a choice but a form of psychic survival.
What makes the sentence work is its hard, balanced rhythm: ought vs must, find vs make. The shift from moral prescription (“ought”) to biological insistence (“must”) collapses the pieties of self-control into something closer to hunger. Bronte isn’t romanticizing restlessness; she’s warning that denying people agency doesn’t create peace, it creates volatility. Tranquility imposed from above is not a stable social order. It’s a lid on a boiling pot.
The subtext is a rebuke to a whole etiquette of containment. In Bronte’s world, tranquility is often code for obedience: for women, especially, a decorative calm that keeps them in their place. By insisting “they will make it if they cannot find it,” she exposes how repression manufactures its own disturbances. If life won’t provide purpose, ambition, romance, danger, meaningful work - humans will improvise substitutes: dramas, scandals, self-sabotage, crusades. Action becomes not just a choice but a form of psychic survival.
What makes the sentence work is its hard, balanced rhythm: ought vs must, find vs make. The shift from moral prescription (“ought”) to biological insistence (“must”) collapses the pieties of self-control into something closer to hunger. Bronte isn’t romanticizing restlessness; she’s warning that denying people agency doesn’t create peace, it creates volatility. Tranquility imposed from above is not a stable social order. It’s a lid on a boiling pot.
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|---|
| Source | Jane Eyre (1847) — Charlotte Brontë; line appears in the novel. Text available in public domain editions. |
More Quotes by Charlotte
Add to List







