"It is very important that our young people have constructive early work experiences. But it is equally important that their jobs are safe and complement their education, rather than complete it"
About this Quote
A single swapped word does a lot of political work here: “complement,” not “complete.” Alexis Herman is drawing a bright line between work as a developmental tool and work as a substitute for schooling, a distinction aimed straight at the quiet economics that push teenagers into long hours and risky jobs. The first sentence offers the consensus bait: early work can build skills, discipline, and confidence. The second sentence tightens the screws, reframing the real issue as power and protection - whether young workers are being shaped by opportunity or siphoned off by necessity.
Herman’s intent is regulatory as much as rhetorical. “Safe” signals labor standards, not just parental concern. “Constructive” and “complement” signal policy priorities: youth employment should be structured around learning, limited in hours, and aligned with educational outcomes, not treated as cheap labor that undermines attendance, performance, or long-term mobility. The subtext is a critique of a culture that praises “hustle” while tolerating conditions that would be unacceptable for adults: hazardous workplaces, weak enforcement, and employers incentivized to schedule minors when they’re most available - nights, weekends, and school days.
Context matters because Herman speaks as a public servant associated with labor policy in an era when “welfare-to-work” logic and low-wage service growth were reshaping adolescence. The quote stakes out a middle position: pro-work, anti-exploitation. It’s a reminder that the real metric of a “good job” for youth isn’t immediate paycheck pride; it’s whether the job expands a future or forecloses it.
Herman’s intent is regulatory as much as rhetorical. “Safe” signals labor standards, not just parental concern. “Constructive” and “complement” signal policy priorities: youth employment should be structured around learning, limited in hours, and aligned with educational outcomes, not treated as cheap labor that undermines attendance, performance, or long-term mobility. The subtext is a critique of a culture that praises “hustle” while tolerating conditions that would be unacceptable for adults: hazardous workplaces, weak enforcement, and employers incentivized to schedule minors when they’re most available - nights, weekends, and school days.
Context matters because Herman speaks as a public servant associated with labor policy in an era when “welfare-to-work” logic and low-wage service growth were reshaping adolescence. The quote stakes out a middle position: pro-work, anti-exploitation. It’s a reminder that the real metric of a “good job” for youth isn’t immediate paycheck pride; it’s whether the job expands a future or forecloses it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|
More Quotes by Alexis
Add to List
