"It is worse than immoral, it's a mistake"
About this Quote
Acheson’s line lands like a diplomatic slap delivered with a lawyer’s calm. By demoting a moral failing into a strategic blunder, he’s not excusing wrongdoing; he’s reaching for a harsher verdict in the language that moves governments. “Immoral” can be argued away, spun as tragic necessity, filed under ideology or righteous cause. “A mistake” is colder and more damning inside a state apparatus: it implies incompetence, misreading of power, avoidable self-harm. In Washington, moral critiques can become theater. Calling something a mistake threatens reputations, careers, and the credibility a superpower trades on.
The context often attached to the phrase is the 1956 Suez Crisis, when Britain, France, and Israel invaded Egypt after Nasser nationalized the canal. Acheson, a principal architect of postwar U.S. foreign policy, understood that the old imperial reflexes weren’t just ethically dubious; they were strategically suicidal in a decolonizing world where legitimacy was the scarce commodity. The subtext is realist but not amoral: moral language is too weak because it can be compartmentalized; strategic error can’t. A “mistake” signals that the action will backfire, strengthen adversaries, fracture alliances, and accelerate the very forces it seeks to control.
The rhetorical trick is its inversion of expected hierarchy. We’re trained to think immorality is the bottom rung. Acheson flips that ladder to speak to leaders who may not fear being wicked but do fear being wrong. It’s a sentence built for the inside game of power: shame them where they’re most vulnerable.
The context often attached to the phrase is the 1956 Suez Crisis, when Britain, France, and Israel invaded Egypt after Nasser nationalized the canal. Acheson, a principal architect of postwar U.S. foreign policy, understood that the old imperial reflexes weren’t just ethically dubious; they were strategically suicidal in a decolonizing world where legitimacy was the scarce commodity. The subtext is realist but not amoral: moral language is too weak because it can be compartmentalized; strategic error can’t. A “mistake” signals that the action will backfire, strengthen adversaries, fracture alliances, and accelerate the very forces it seeks to control.
The rhetorical trick is its inversion of expected hierarchy. We’re trained to think immorality is the bottom rung. Acheson flips that ladder to speak to leaders who may not fear being wicked but do fear being wrong. It’s a sentence built for the inside game of power: shame them where they’re most vulnerable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Dean
Add to List
