"It seems to me that good novels celebrate the mystery in ordinary life, and summing it all up in psychological terms strips the mystery away"
About this Quote
Tyler is defending the novel as a refuge from our era's favorite compulsion: turning lived experience into a case study. Her phrasing is deceptively mild - "It seems to me" - but it's doing pointed cultural work, pushing back on the idea that a tidy diagnosis equals understanding. In her hands, "psychological terms" isn't a neutral toolbox; it's a solvent. It dissolves the ambiguity that makes ordinary life feel electrically strange when you actually pay attention.
The key word is "celebrate". Tyler isn't arguing that people are unknowable in some mystical sense. She's arguing that fiction's job is to honor the everyday as irreducible: a spouse's offhand comment that lands like a verdict, a neighbor's quiet rituals, the way families rewrite their own history in real time. When you "sum it all up", you compress that texture into causality - trauma explains X, attachment style explains Y - and the narrative becomes less a world than a report.
The subtext is also aesthetic. Tyler's novels are famously domestic, often set in the small dramas of Baltimore kitchens and living rooms. She elevates the "ordinary" not by making it sensational, but by refusing to treat it as merely symptomatic. That stance reads like a rebuke to both pop-therapy culture and a certain brand of literary criticism that wants the master key. Mystery, here, isn't ignorance; it's respect for complexity, and for the fact that people exceed the stories we tell about them.
The key word is "celebrate". Tyler isn't arguing that people are unknowable in some mystical sense. She's arguing that fiction's job is to honor the everyday as irreducible: a spouse's offhand comment that lands like a verdict, a neighbor's quiet rituals, the way families rewrite their own history in real time. When you "sum it all up", you compress that texture into causality - trauma explains X, attachment style explains Y - and the narrative becomes less a world than a report.
The subtext is also aesthetic. Tyler's novels are famously domestic, often set in the small dramas of Baltimore kitchens and living rooms. She elevates the "ordinary" not by making it sensational, but by refusing to treat it as merely symptomatic. That stance reads like a rebuke to both pop-therapy culture and a certain brand of literary criticism that wants the master key. Mystery, here, isn't ignorance; it's respect for complexity, and for the fact that people exceed the stories we tell about them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Anne
Add to List




