"It vexes me when they would constrain science by the authority of the Scriptures, and yet do not consider themselves bound to answer reason and experiment"
About this Quote
Galileo’s irritation isn’t just personal pique; it’s a strategic recoil from a power play. “It vexes me” sounds almost quaint, but the restraint is the point: he frames the conflict as an avoidable category error, not a heretical brawl. The target isn’t faith itself so much as a double standard - people who demand that science kneel before Scripture while exempting themselves from the basic obligations of inquiry. In one sentence, he names the asymmetry that still defines culture-war fights: you must obey my authority, I need not engage your evidence.
The verb “constrain” does heavy work. It suggests science is being physically bound, limited by an external leash. Galileo casts scientific practice as something with its own jurisdiction, governed by “reason and experiment” rather than by textual adjudication. That pairing is deliberate: reason without experiment is scholastic cleverness; experiment without reason is noise. He’s staking out a method as a moral standard - not just how to know, but how to argue in good faith.
Context sharpens the edge. Galileo is writing in a world where Scripture isn’t merely a book; it’s an institutional weapon, backed by courts, patronage, and the threat of punishment. He can’t say, “You’re wrong”; he says, “You’re refusing to play by the rules you impose on others.” It’s an early modern version of calling out bad-faith debate, delivered with the calm of someone who knows the telescope will win eventually, even if he won’t.
The verb “constrain” does heavy work. It suggests science is being physically bound, limited by an external leash. Galileo casts scientific practice as something with its own jurisdiction, governed by “reason and experiment” rather than by textual adjudication. That pairing is deliberate: reason without experiment is scholastic cleverness; experiment without reason is noise. He’s staking out a method as a moral standard - not just how to know, but how to argue in good faith.
Context sharpens the edge. Galileo is writing in a world where Scripture isn’t merely a book; it’s an institutional weapon, backed by courts, patronage, and the threat of punishment. He can’t say, “You’re wrong”; he says, “You’re refusing to play by the rules you impose on others.” It’s an early modern version of calling out bad-faith debate, delivered with the calm of someone who knows the telescope will win eventually, even if he won’t.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|
More Quotes by Galileo
Add to List
