"It was in the Papal States that I studied the Roman Question. I traveled over every part of the country; I conversed with men of all opinions, examined things very closely, and collected my information on the spot"
About this Quote
There is something deliciously strategic in how Edmond About frames his authority here: not as a theorist with a desk and a doctrine, but as a self-appointed investigator who claims he has walked the ground, shaken the hands, and gathered the receipts. The line reads like a passport stamp turned into a credential. In the mid-19th century, the "Roman Question" wasnt an abstract puzzle; it was the live wire of Italian unification and papal sovereignty, with France, Austria, and local factions all tugging at the same sacred-and-political rope. About signals that he went to the Papal States precisely because the argument couldnt be settled from Paris.
The subtext is a performance of neutrality that knows it will be read as persuasion. "Men of all opinions" is the key phrase: it stages open-mindedness while quietly implying that the author has already done what armchair critics havent. "Examined things very closely" and "on the spot" echoes the era's faith in reportage and modern expertise, a secular habit of mind applied to a theocratic state. That tension is the point. A novelist writing like a field correspondent is already smuggling in a critique: the Vatican's temporal power is treated as a system to be audited, not a mystery to be revered.
Abouts intent, then, is not merely to inform but to preempt skepticism. He builds a hard shell of credibility before he delivers whatever softer, sharper judgments his readers are meant to swallow. In a debate loaded with ideology, he sells proximity as truth.
The subtext is a performance of neutrality that knows it will be read as persuasion. "Men of all opinions" is the key phrase: it stages open-mindedness while quietly implying that the author has already done what armchair critics havent. "Examined things very closely" and "on the spot" echoes the era's faith in reportage and modern expertise, a secular habit of mind applied to a theocratic state. That tension is the point. A novelist writing like a field correspondent is already smuggling in a critique: the Vatican's temporal power is treated as a system to be audited, not a mystery to be revered.
Abouts intent, then, is not merely to inform but to preempt skepticism. He builds a hard shell of credibility before he delivers whatever softer, sharper judgments his readers are meant to swallow. In a debate loaded with ideology, he sells proximity as truth.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|
More Quotes by Edmond
Add to List






