"It was Rousseau who was largely responsible for the problem by giving currency to the idea that freedom can exist without responsibility and discipline"
About this Quote
Wilson goes for Rousseau’s throat because Rousseau is the patron saint of a very modern temptation: treating freedom as a mood rather than a practice. The line is engineered to puncture the romantic myth that the “natural” self, once unshackled, will automatically flower into virtue. Wilson’s target isn’t just an 18th-century philosopher; it’s a whole cultural alibi that lets people confuse impulse with authenticity and call it liberation.
The specific intent is corrective and polemical. By naming Rousseau, Wilson gives the “problem” a pedigree, as if today’s flakiness and anti-authoritarian reflex have an intellectual paper trail. “Giving currency” is a sly, economic verb: Rousseau didn’t invent the fantasy so much as mint it, making it spendable in public life. Wilson implies that once a society starts circulating this idea, it becomes harder to argue for self-command without sounding like a scold.
Subtext: the crisis of freedom is internal, not political. Wilson’s freedom isn’t the absence of constraints; it’s a disciplined capacity to choose, built through habits, attention, and responsibility. That fits his broader existential preoccupation with human potential and the refusal to live at the level of mere reaction.
Contextually, it’s a mid-20th-century writer watching postwar affluence, permissiveness, and countercultural rhetoric turn “do what you want” into a moral stance. Wilson’s provocation works because it reverses the sentimental script: discipline, usually cast as the enemy of liberty, becomes its prerequisite. The barb lands on readers who want the rights of freedom without the strenuous, unglamorous labor that makes freedom real.
The specific intent is corrective and polemical. By naming Rousseau, Wilson gives the “problem” a pedigree, as if today’s flakiness and anti-authoritarian reflex have an intellectual paper trail. “Giving currency” is a sly, economic verb: Rousseau didn’t invent the fantasy so much as mint it, making it spendable in public life. Wilson implies that once a society starts circulating this idea, it becomes harder to argue for self-command without sounding like a scold.
Subtext: the crisis of freedom is internal, not political. Wilson’s freedom isn’t the absence of constraints; it’s a disciplined capacity to choose, built through habits, attention, and responsibility. That fits his broader existential preoccupation with human potential and the refusal to live at the level of mere reaction.
Contextually, it’s a mid-20th-century writer watching postwar affluence, permissiveness, and countercultural rhetoric turn “do what you want” into a moral stance. Wilson’s provocation works because it reverses the sentimental script: discipline, usually cast as the enemy of liberty, becomes its prerequisite. The barb lands on readers who want the rights of freedom without the strenuous, unglamorous labor that makes freedom real.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Colin
Add to List
