"It was wrong to allow Stalin to shape the European landscape of the 20th century. It would be even more wrong to let him shape the landscape of the 21st century"
About this Quote
Summers is doing something economists rarely get credit for: writing in moral absolutes. “Wrong” appears twice, a blunt ethical verdict that refuses the usual technocratic refuge of “trade-offs.” The line works because it yokes policy to memory. It doesn’t argue Stalin’s legacy; it treats it as settled history and then pivots to the more uncomfortable claim that legacy can be re-authored in the present.
The phrase “shape the European landscape” is slyly expansive. It gestures at borders and buffer states, but also at institutions, habits of fear, coerced silence, and the long shadow of what got normalized under Soviet dominance. “Landscape” sounds almost natural, as if geography itself were molded, which is precisely the point: authoritarian outcomes can harden into the background people stop questioning.
The real punch is the time-traveling accusation embedded in “let him.” Stalin is dead; the enabling isn’t his. Summers is targeting contemporary actors who, through strategic cynicism or complacency, allow Russian power politics (and the argument that Eastern Europe is negotiable) to re-enter as common sense. It’s a warning about the politics of resignation: the idea that spheres of influence are inevitable, that small countries are chess squares, that stability is worth moral blur.
Contextually, the quote fits a post-Cold War tension that spikes whenever Western leaders flirt with “reset” fantasies or treat Eastern European sovereignty as a bargaining chip. Summers frames that temptation as not merely mistaken policy but a second, avoidable moral failure - a rerun with better excuses.
The phrase “shape the European landscape” is slyly expansive. It gestures at borders and buffer states, but also at institutions, habits of fear, coerced silence, and the long shadow of what got normalized under Soviet dominance. “Landscape” sounds almost natural, as if geography itself were molded, which is precisely the point: authoritarian outcomes can harden into the background people stop questioning.
The real punch is the time-traveling accusation embedded in “let him.” Stalin is dead; the enabling isn’t his. Summers is targeting contemporary actors who, through strategic cynicism or complacency, allow Russian power politics (and the argument that Eastern Europe is negotiable) to re-enter as common sense. It’s a warning about the politics of resignation: the idea that spheres of influence are inevitable, that small countries are chess squares, that stability is worth moral blur.
Contextually, the quote fits a post-Cold War tension that spikes whenever Western leaders flirt with “reset” fantasies or treat Eastern European sovereignty as a bargaining chip. Summers frames that temptation as not merely mistaken policy but a second, avoidable moral failure - a rerun with better excuses.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Lawrence
Add to List
