"It will always be the same possibilities, in sum or on the average, that go on repeating themselves until a man comes along who does not value the actuality above idea. It is he who first gives the new possibilities their meaning, their direction, and he awakens them"
About this Quote
History, Musil suggests, is less a parade of new events than a loop of recycled options. “The same possibilities” keep reappearing because most of us treat the world’s current shape as more authoritative than the concepts that could reorganize it. That’s a quietly brutal diagnosis: the limiting factor isn’t scarcity of alternatives but our loyalty to what’s already been ratified by habit, institutions, and fear of looking naïve.
Musil’s pivot is the figure “who does not value the actuality above idea.” In other words, the rare person for whom “the way things are” doesn’t automatically outrank “the way things could be.” The subtext isn’t airy idealism; it’s a theory of agency. Possibilities, left unattended, are inert. They exist as background noise until someone imposes meaning and direction, turning potential into a program. His phrasing makes that act feel almost physiological: the innovator doesn’t invent possibilities so much as awaken them, like stirring a sleeping limb back into sensation.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of a collapsing Austro-Hungarian world and the ideological convulsions of early 20th-century Europe, Musil had reason to doubt “actuality” as a moral compass. The old order proved both real and disastrously stupid. The line reads as both warning and temptation: if the future belongs to those who privilege ideas, that includes visionaries and fanatics alike. Musil’s irony is that imagination is a power tool - neutral in itself, decisive in whoever grips it.
Musil’s pivot is the figure “who does not value the actuality above idea.” In other words, the rare person for whom “the way things are” doesn’t automatically outrank “the way things could be.” The subtext isn’t airy idealism; it’s a theory of agency. Possibilities, left unattended, are inert. They exist as background noise until someone imposes meaning and direction, turning potential into a program. His phrasing makes that act feel almost physiological: the innovator doesn’t invent possibilities so much as awaken them, like stirring a sleeping limb back into sensation.
Context matters. Writing in the shadow of a collapsing Austro-Hungarian world and the ideological convulsions of early 20th-century Europe, Musil had reason to doubt “actuality” as a moral compass. The old order proved both real and disastrously stupid. The line reads as both warning and temptation: if the future belongs to those who privilege ideas, that includes visionaries and fanatics alike. Musil’s irony is that imagination is a power tool - neutral in itself, decisive in whoever grips it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
