"It would be difficult to exaggerate the degree to which we are influenced by those we influence"
About this Quote
A tidy inversion like this is Hoffer at his best: a sentence that looks like a mild observation until it reveals a trapdoor. We like to imagine influence as a one-way current flowing outward from the confident to the persuadable. Hoffer flips it and makes the hidden dependency visible: the people we lead, teach, or persuade don’t just receive our ideas, they quietly reshape them.
The intent is corrective. Hoffer, writing in the long shadow of mass movements and ideological fervor, is wary of anyone who thinks they can steer crowds without being altered by the steering. The subtext is psychological and political: every influencer becomes, in part, an employee of their audience. If you’re a preacher, you start sermonizing to the congregation you’ve cultivated; if you’re a boss, you become the manager your team’s expectations train you to be; if you’re an activist, you can end up performing the cause in the idiom that keeps supporters energized. Influence creates feedback loops, and the loop doesn’t care about your self-image.
The phrasing matters. “Difficult to exaggerate” isn’t just emphasis; it’s a jab at our chronic underestimation of reciprocity. “Those we influence” is impersonal, almost clinical, as if Hoffer is talking about a force of nature rather than friends or followers. That distance sharpens the warning: the more power you claim over others, the more you should suspect you’re being shaped in return. The line punctures the fantasy of untouched authority and replaces it with a messier truth: leadership is a relationship, and relationships leave fingerprints.
The intent is corrective. Hoffer, writing in the long shadow of mass movements and ideological fervor, is wary of anyone who thinks they can steer crowds without being altered by the steering. The subtext is psychological and political: every influencer becomes, in part, an employee of their audience. If you’re a preacher, you start sermonizing to the congregation you’ve cultivated; if you’re a boss, you become the manager your team’s expectations train you to be; if you’re an activist, you can end up performing the cause in the idiom that keeps supporters energized. Influence creates feedback loops, and the loop doesn’t care about your self-image.
The phrasing matters. “Difficult to exaggerate” isn’t just emphasis; it’s a jab at our chronic underestimation of reciprocity. “Those we influence” is impersonal, almost clinical, as if Hoffer is talking about a force of nature rather than friends or followers. That distance sharpens the warning: the more power you claim over others, the more you should suspect you’re being shaped in return. The line punctures the fantasy of untouched authority and replaces it with a messier truth: leadership is a relationship, and relationships leave fingerprints.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List
