"It wouldn't sit easily on one's conscience that you had been warned and there could be danger, but nevertheless you went ahead and said let's dispense these drugs"
About this Quote
Mbeki’s line reads like a moral alibi written in advance. The phrasing does a lot of political work: it shifts the frame from public health outcomes to personal conscience, from evidence to warning, from responsibility to discomfort. “It wouldn’t sit easily” is soft language for a hard consequence. He’s not saying the drugs are dangerous; he’s saying someone has told you they might be, and that alone should trouble you enough to stop. In other words, uncertainty becomes the veto.
The subtext is caution weaponized as virtue. By centering “you had been warned,” Mbeki implies that proceeding would be reckless, almost immoral, regardless of the balance of probabilities. It’s a rhetorical move that elevates prudence while quietly absolving the speaker of accountability for what follows: if harm occurs, it’s because others “went ahead.” If harm occurs from not acting, the blame dissipates into the fog of “danger” and “conscience.”
Context sharpens the stakes. Mbeki’s presidency was marked by South Africa’s catastrophic HIV/AIDS policy battles, including skepticism toward antiretroviral treatment and delays in rolling it out through the public system. In that environment, “let’s dispense these drugs” isn’t neutral technocratic language; it’s the life-or-death decision to treat millions. The quote captures how leaders can launder ideological doubt through ethical language, turning an appeal to responsibility into a rationale for paralysis.
The subtext is caution weaponized as virtue. By centering “you had been warned,” Mbeki implies that proceeding would be reckless, almost immoral, regardless of the balance of probabilities. It’s a rhetorical move that elevates prudence while quietly absolving the speaker of accountability for what follows: if harm occurs, it’s because others “went ahead.” If harm occurs from not acting, the blame dissipates into the fog of “danger” and “conscience.”
Context sharpens the stakes. Mbeki’s presidency was marked by South Africa’s catastrophic HIV/AIDS policy battles, including skepticism toward antiretroviral treatment and delays in rolling it out through the public system. In that environment, “let’s dispense these drugs” isn’t neutral technocratic language; it’s the life-or-death decision to treat millions. The quote captures how leaders can launder ideological doubt through ethical language, turning an appeal to responsibility into a rationale for paralysis.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Thabo
Add to List
