"It's better to give than to lend and it costs about the same"
About this Quote
A journalist’s trick is to compress a whole moral argument into something that sounds like bookkeeping, and Gibbs does it with a wink. “It’s better to give than to lend” flips the familiar piety of “give than receive” into a harder, more adult claim: lending isn’t generosity, it’s a relationship contract. It creates a ledger between people, a quiet hierarchy of creditor and debtor that can sour friendships faster than the money ever helped.
The kicker, “and it costs about the same,” is Gibbs’s sly demolition of the self-image lenders like to keep. We tell ourselves a loan is pragmatic kindness: I’m helping, but I’m not a sucker. Gibbs implies you pay either way. If you lend, you risk the same financial loss, plus interest in a different currency: resentment, awkward follow-ups, the little internal audits of someone else’s life. Even when the money comes back, the emotional cost can exceed the principal.
Context matters: Gibbs lived through an era when informal credit - between neighbors, relatives, colleagues - often substituted for institutional safety nets, especially during wartime and interwar strain. In that world, the “loan” was rarely neutral; it carried social surveillance and obligation. His line urges a cleaner ethic: if you can’t afford to give, don’t lend. It’s less saintly than it sounds. It’s a strategy for preserving dignity on both sides by removing the trapdoor of expectation.
The kicker, “and it costs about the same,” is Gibbs’s sly demolition of the self-image lenders like to keep. We tell ourselves a loan is pragmatic kindness: I’m helping, but I’m not a sucker. Gibbs implies you pay either way. If you lend, you risk the same financial loss, plus interest in a different currency: resentment, awkward follow-ups, the little internal audits of someone else’s life. Even when the money comes back, the emotional cost can exceed the principal.
Context matters: Gibbs lived through an era when informal credit - between neighbors, relatives, colleagues - often substituted for institutional safety nets, especially during wartime and interwar strain. In that world, the “loan” was rarely neutral; it carried social surveillance and obligation. His line urges a cleaner ethic: if you can’t afford to give, don’t lend. It’s less saintly than it sounds. It’s a strategy for preserving dignity on both sides by removing the trapdoor of expectation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Philip
Add to List





