"It's hard to compare. Different times, different players. The administration four years ago did not have 9/11. I could tell you this; this particular administration was better suited to handle that than the former"
About this Quote
The sentence does a careful rhetorical two-step: it opens with humility, then slips in a sharp political judgment. “It’s hard to compare. Different times, different players” sounds like the TV-friendly posture of fairness, a way to preempt the audience’s eye-roll at partisan hot takes. But it’s also a setup. By insisting that history can’t be cleanly measured across administrations, Williams lowers the bar for evidence and raises the appeal of instinct: you can’t prove it, but you can feel it.
Then comes the hinge: “The administration four years ago did not have 9/11.” That line quietly frames 9/11 as the ultimate stress test, the event that rewrites the scoreboard. It implies the prior administration (implicitly Clinton’s, given the timeline) never faced the defining crisis, so critiques of the current one should be tempered. It’s a subtle reframing of accountability: if the conditions changed, the standards should, too.
“I could tell you this” signals personal credibility, not policy expertise. As an entertainer, Williams leans into ethos-by-proximity: the authority of a public figure who has watched, listened, and absorbed the national mood. The clincher - “better suited to handle that” - is less about competence than temperament. It suggests a preference for a certain kind of governing masculinity: resolute, militarized, willing to act. The subtext is cultural, not procedural: after trauma, Americans often reward the image of decisiveness, even when the outcomes are contested.
Then comes the hinge: “The administration four years ago did not have 9/11.” That line quietly frames 9/11 as the ultimate stress test, the event that rewrites the scoreboard. It implies the prior administration (implicitly Clinton’s, given the timeline) never faced the defining crisis, so critiques of the current one should be tempered. It’s a subtle reframing of accountability: if the conditions changed, the standards should, too.
“I could tell you this” signals personal credibility, not policy expertise. As an entertainer, Williams leans into ethos-by-proximity: the authority of a public figure who has watched, listened, and absorbed the national mood. The clincher - “better suited to handle that” - is less about competence than temperament. It suggests a preference for a certain kind of governing masculinity: resolute, militarized, willing to act. The subtext is cultural, not procedural: after trauma, Americans often reward the image of decisiveness, even when the outcomes are contested.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|
More Quotes by Montel
Add to List
