"It's impossible for someone who is human to have all good things together, just as there is no single country able to provide all good things for itself"
About this Quote
Herodotus is smuggling a hard political truth into what sounds like simple folk wisdom: perfection is not just unlikely, its structurally unavailable. By pairing the human body with the body politic, he turns private desire into an international lesson. Individuals fantasize about a life with no tradeoffs; states fantasize about self-sufficiency. Both fantasies break on the same rock: limits, chance, and dependency.
The line lands in the context of a Greek world stitched together by ships, tribute, and rivalry, where the Persian Wars had made “greatness” look both exhilarating and precarious. Herodotus spends much of his Histories showing how prosperity invites overreach and how power invites blindness. So “all good things together” isn’t a self-help aphorism; it’s a warning shot against hubris. The subtext is almost economic before economics: countries, like people, need exchange. No polis has every resource, every talent, every strategic advantage. Trying to hoard them all leads to conquest, and conquest invites the kind of reversal Herodotus loves to narrate.
What makes the formulation work is its calm refusal to moralize. He doesn’t say “don’t be greedy” or “be humble.” He says: the universe is arranged against your total win. That cool, comparative framing lets him critique imperial ambition without naming a villain, even as his broader project keeps circling the same theme - fortunes rise, fortunes fall, and the demand for completeness is often the first step toward catastrophe.
The line lands in the context of a Greek world stitched together by ships, tribute, and rivalry, where the Persian Wars had made “greatness” look both exhilarating and precarious. Herodotus spends much of his Histories showing how prosperity invites overreach and how power invites blindness. So “all good things together” isn’t a self-help aphorism; it’s a warning shot against hubris. The subtext is almost economic before economics: countries, like people, need exchange. No polis has every resource, every talent, every strategic advantage. Trying to hoard them all leads to conquest, and conquest invites the kind of reversal Herodotus loves to narrate.
What makes the formulation work is its calm refusal to moralize. He doesn’t say “don’t be greedy” or “be humble.” He says: the universe is arranged against your total win. That cool, comparative framing lets him critique imperial ambition without naming a villain, even as his broader project keeps circling the same theme - fortunes rise, fortunes fall, and the demand for completeness is often the first step toward catastrophe.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Herodotus
Add to List
