Art & Creativity Quote by Jonny Greenwood

"It's like that scene from The Player when they talk about merging Star Wars and Kramer vs. Kramer, or whatever. You could do that with music and it would just be awful"

Jonny Greenwood, Musician

About this Quote

Greenwood is skewering the entertainment industrys talent for turning every idea into a market-tested smoothie. By reaching for The Player a Hollywood satire about cynically packaging art Greenwood signals hes not just talking about taste hes talking about power. The joke in that film is that a grotesque mashup Star Wars plus Kramer vs. Kramer is pitched as visionary because it can be sold to everyone. Greenwood hears the same impulse lurking in music: the pressure to splice genres eras and emotional registers not because the combination reveals something new but because it widens the demographic net.

The offhand or whatever matters. Hes mimicking the way executives treat actual works as interchangeable brand tokens. Star Wars isnt a movie here its a synonym for spectacle and merch. Kramer vs. Kramer becomes shorthand for prestige and tears. Put them together and you get a Franken-product with the sheen of ambition and none of the moral center. Greenwood is warning that music can be flattened the same way: collaborations engineered by label logic playlists designed to keep listeners from skipping stylistic whiplash sold as innovation.

Theres also a self-protective edge. As someone known for pushing rock into orchestral electronic and avant-garde territory he draws a line between hybridization that comes from obsession and craft and hybridization that comes from a conference room. His target isnt genre-crossing its the cynical kind where the seams arent part of the art theyre the sales pitch.

Quote Details

Topic	Music
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Jonny Add to List

About the Author

Jonny Greenwood (born November 5, 1971) is a Musician from England.

18 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"You go back to those films of the '40s and '50s and hear the dialogue, the way the people played off each other, the wordplay. I think we've really lost that in movies"

Clive Owen, Actor

"It was my first scene in any movie and my only scene in Kramer vs. Kramer. I was petrified"

JoBeth Williams, Actress

"When the movie's done, you talk about either the score or source music over a particular scene, what might work. You just throw a piece of music over the scene, and we both listen to it"

Ethan Coen, Director

"Any time you get two people in a room who disagree about anything, the time of day, there is a scene to be written. That's what I look for"

Aaron Sorkin, Producer

"If it's a good movie, the sound could go off and the audience would still have a perfectly clear idea of what was going on"

Alfred Hitchcock, Director

Alfred Hitchcock

"One of the things I particularly enjoyed doing was taking raw sound from locations during the film, like the candy machine, and writing pieces of music to go with them, which is totally unnecessary within the context of the film, because they have their own logic"

Fred Frith, Composer

"When I do the music, I make the musicians listen to what's happening in the film. That way they treat the dialogue as if it was a singer"

Mike Figgis, Director

"With the fight scenes, they would take a video camera and shoot alongside the camera so we would piece it together on the computer and had an extremely rough cut of what we were doing"

Kelly Hu, Actress

"The ideal situation would be to bypass all of the drama and mayhem and just get the music right to the people. I'm confident that we'll eventually figure it out"

Debbie Gibson, Musician

"Adding sound to movies would be like putting lipstick on the Venus de Milo"

Mary Pickford, Actress

"But, yeah, I'd love to do something else in someone else's movie"

Jason Mewes, Actor

"I don't know if I'd want to do that anymore, because you always get bigger laughs on college campuses. So, when the film plays in front of a city audience, you've probably cut too loosely"

David Zucker, Director

"That's always something that's really important for an actor - to find an opportunity to do a scene where there is a moment like that, where you manage to connect with everyone"

Bruce Davison, Actor

"The actor is concerned with his own bit of it, but the director's somehow trying to work the whole thing into a much bigger picture. It's like conducting an orchestra"

Roland Joffe, Director

"But here I am today recording this and I'm in the studio with all the others on a clean mic. It's extraordinary, the actor's found a way of doing it for himself"

John Leeson, Actor

"It was a scene in the sense that we were all close and we all knew each other before the different bands had really formed. We used to rehearse in the same place"

Arto Lindsay, Musician

"I wouldn't mind producing a movie with a music storyline, but acting in one is too close to home"

Garth Brooks, Musician

"To some extent at that time, we injected rock and roll into that scene- we played loud and that was a huge turning point for that scene. We were involved in playing with all those people"

Arto Lindsay, Musician

"It was one of the marvellous feelings of the film, having the music going in your head while doing scenes"

Dinah Sheridan, Actress

Dinah Sheridan

"Now, it's almost impossible to go out and do a film about a new form of music"

Penelope Spheeris, Director