"It's like turning the space program over to the Long Island Railroad"
About this Quote
Handing the space program to the Long Island Railroad is a one-line demolition: a vivid, almost unfair comparison that makes bureaucratic incompetence feel tactile. David R. Brower, the grandmaster of 20th-century American environmental agitation, isn’t offering a policy critique so much as a warning about institutional temperament. NASA, in the popular imagination, is precision, daring, and a certain kind of national competence. The Long Island Railroad, meanwhile, carries the commuter’s folklore of delays, grinding routine, and system fatigue. Brower’s intent is to puncture techno-triumphalism with a transit-platform sneer: if you let the wrong kind of organization run the show, even the most exalted mission becomes just another late train.
The subtext is about what happens when visionary projects are captured by managers whose incentives reward stability, box-checking, and cost containment over discovery. Brower’s environmental battles often turned on that exact tension: agencies and corporations promising progress while delivering paperwork, compromised outcomes, and infrastructure that mainly serves existing power. The joke lands because it’s not anti-science; it’s anti-bureaucracy dressed up as science.
Contextually, Brower came of age in an era that worshipped megaprojects, from dams to rockets, and he spent his career insisting that scale and spectacle aren’t synonyms for wisdom. The line reads as a cultural correction: ambition without imagination becomes maintenance, and maintenance without accountability becomes farce. It’s also a sly reminder that public trust is fragile; once competence feels like commuter fiction, even moonshots start to look like missed connections.
The subtext is about what happens when visionary projects are captured by managers whose incentives reward stability, box-checking, and cost containment over discovery. Brower’s environmental battles often turned on that exact tension: agencies and corporations promising progress while delivering paperwork, compromised outcomes, and infrastructure that mainly serves existing power. The joke lands because it’s not anti-science; it’s anti-bureaucracy dressed up as science.
Contextually, Brower came of age in an era that worshipped megaprojects, from dams to rockets, and he spent his career insisting that scale and spectacle aren’t synonyms for wisdom. The line reads as a cultural correction: ambition without imagination becomes maintenance, and maintenance without accountability becomes farce. It’s also a sly reminder that public trust is fragile; once competence feels like commuter fiction, even moonshots start to look like missed connections.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List
