"It's not in baseball's interest or the players' interest to be taking this stance. It's the people's game"
About this Quote
Vincent’s line is a lawyerly warning dressed up as a love letter to tradition: keep fighting and you’ll lose the jury. By invoking “baseball’s interest” and “the players’ interest,” he frames a labor dispute as a mutual self-own, not a moral crusade. The phrase “taking this stance” is strategically vague, a way to scold without litigating specifics in public. That’s classic commissioner-era rhetoric: don’t debate the terms, question the posture.
Then comes the pivot that does the real work: “It’s the people’s game.” Vincent isn’t just praising fandom; he’s relocating ownership of the sport’s legitimacy. If baseball belongs to “the people,” then players and owners become stewards who can be judged, shamed, and punished at the gate and on TV. It’s soft power: a reminder that the public’s patience is finite, and that the most dangerous strikebreaker isn’t a replacement roster but indifference.
The subtext is also a subtle flattening of labor politics. Calling it “the people’s game” sounds democratic, but it can function as a cudgel against players asserting leverage, as if collective bargaining is a betrayal of the pastime’s civic aura. Vincent, a lawyer by training and a commissioner by temperament, is trying to preserve baseball’s most valuable asset: cultural innocence. When negotiations get too explicit - about billions, not box scores - the illusion that the game sits above normal capitalism cracks. His sentence is a plea to keep the business of baseball from looking like business at all.
Then comes the pivot that does the real work: “It’s the people’s game.” Vincent isn’t just praising fandom; he’s relocating ownership of the sport’s legitimacy. If baseball belongs to “the people,” then players and owners become stewards who can be judged, shamed, and punished at the gate and on TV. It’s soft power: a reminder that the public’s patience is finite, and that the most dangerous strikebreaker isn’t a replacement roster but indifference.
The subtext is also a subtle flattening of labor politics. Calling it “the people’s game” sounds democratic, but it can function as a cudgel against players asserting leverage, as if collective bargaining is a betrayal of the pastime’s civic aura. Vincent, a lawyer by training and a commissioner by temperament, is trying to preserve baseball’s most valuable asset: cultural innocence. When negotiations get too explicit - about billions, not box scores - the illusion that the game sits above normal capitalism cracks. His sentence is a plea to keep the business of baseball from looking like business at all.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sports |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Fay
Add to List




