"It's not surprising, then, they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations"
About this Quote
The line lands like a diagnosis delivered with a wince: not just an observation about resentment, but a theory of how it gets metabolized into identity. Obama’s intent is explanatory, almost sociological, yet the rhetoric is unmistakably political. “It’s not surprising” does quiet work up front, reframing anger as predictable rather than pathological. That move tries to disarm moral panic and redirect attention to causes upstream: dislocation, status loss, the slow violence of economic change.
Then comes the risky part: the catalogue. “Guns or religion” aren’t offered here as principled commitments but as objects you “cling” to, a verb that codes them as comfort blankets. By pairing them with “antipathy” and a string of “anti-” sentiments, the sentence collapses very different motivations into one emotional mechanism. That compression is the point and the problem. It’s meant to expose how frustration can be converted into scapegoating; it also sounds, to many listeners, like an elite’s summary of other people’s bad coping skills.
The subtext is a cultural map of “real America” politics, with grievance as the fuel and symbolic issues as the spark. Context matters: Obama made versions of this argument while running in 2008, when Democrats were struggling to understand why economically strained voters could still reject them. The quote tries to reclaim empathy without surrendering critique. Its effectiveness comes from its clarity about the feedback loop between insecurity and tribal politics; its backlash comes from the same clarity, which can read as condescension even when it’s aiming for compassion.
Then comes the risky part: the catalogue. “Guns or religion” aren’t offered here as principled commitments but as objects you “cling” to, a verb that codes them as comfort blankets. By pairing them with “antipathy” and a string of “anti-” sentiments, the sentence collapses very different motivations into one emotional mechanism. That compression is the point and the problem. It’s meant to expose how frustration can be converted into scapegoating; it also sounds, to many listeners, like an elite’s summary of other people’s bad coping skills.
The subtext is a cultural map of “real America” politics, with grievance as the fuel and symbolic issues as the spark. Context matters: Obama made versions of this argument while running in 2008, when Democrats were struggling to understand why economically strained voters could still reject them. The quote tries to reclaim empathy without surrendering critique. Its effectiveness comes from its clarity about the feedback loop between insecurity and tribal politics; its backlash comes from the same clarity, which can read as condescension even when it’s aiming for compassion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | A More Perfect Union (speech), Barack Obama, March 18, 2008, Philadelphia — transcript contains the line including "It's not surprising, then, that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion..." |
More Quotes by Barack
Add to List




