"Its one thing to be tempted, another thing to fall"
About this Quote
Shakespeare slices moral life into two beats: the pulse of desire, then the choice that turns desire into damage. The line’s power is its cool legalism - “one thing” versus “another” - as if the speaker is cross-examining the soul. Temptation is framed as weather: it happens to you. Falling is framed as gravity you agree to. That distinction matters in Shakespeare because his characters are rarely pure villains; they’re people arguing themselves into permission.
The subtext is less about saintly self-control than about accountability. Shakespeare’s world is crowded with alibis: I was provoked, bewitched, misled, inflamed. The phrasing grants the audience a brief, human concession (you can be tempted) while tightening the moral noose (you still chose to fall). It’s a line that lets a character confess without fully surrendering, a rhetorical halfway house between innocence and guilt.
In the plays, temptation often arrives dressed as intimacy: a confidant’s whisper, a lover’s touch, a rival’s insinuation. “Fall” is the moment private appetite becomes public consequence - a broken vow, a toppled king, a death set in motion. The language also carries the sexual charge of “falling,” the early modern linkage of sin with bodily descent, especially for women whose “fall” becomes social exile.
Shakespeare isn’t naïvely optimistic about resisting temptation; he’s forensic about the instant when temptation becomes narrative. That’s the dramatic engine: not the urge, but the decision that makes tragedy inevitable.
The subtext is less about saintly self-control than about accountability. Shakespeare’s world is crowded with alibis: I was provoked, bewitched, misled, inflamed. The phrasing grants the audience a brief, human concession (you can be tempted) while tightening the moral noose (you still chose to fall). It’s a line that lets a character confess without fully surrendering, a rhetorical halfway house between innocence and guilt.
In the plays, temptation often arrives dressed as intimacy: a confidant’s whisper, a lover’s touch, a rival’s insinuation. “Fall” is the moment private appetite becomes public consequence - a broken vow, a toppled king, a death set in motion. The language also carries the sexual charge of “falling,” the early modern linkage of sin with bodily descent, especially for women whose “fall” becomes social exile.
Shakespeare isn’t naïvely optimistic about resisting temptation; he’s forensic about the instant when temptation becomes narrative. That’s the dramatic engine: not the urge, but the decision that makes tragedy inevitable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Discipline |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List








