"It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear power station to remind us that atomic energy is extraordinarily dangerous"
About this Quote
The "radioactive cloud" is chosen for its brutal clarity. Nuclear danger is famously hard to sense - no smell, no color, no immediate pain - which makes it politically convenient and psychologically easy to deny. Schaeffer flips that invisibility into an image that can't be spun: a cloud announces itself, crosses borders, settles in lungs and soil. It turns "local incident" into communal vulnerability, collapsing the distance between expert systems and ordinary bodies.
Coming from a composer associated with the postwar European avant-garde, the critique lands as more than policy talk. It's about how societies process catastrophe: through recurring shocks, not sustained attention. In the decades after Hiroshima and into the era of reactor accidents and Cold War brinkmanship, atomic power was sold as clean, modern, even elegant - a technological sublime. Schaeffer punctures that aesthetic. His word "ridiculous" isn't casual; it's moral impatience aimed at institutions that normalize extraordinary hazard, and at citizens who let novelty, convenience, and official reassurance dull the capacity to remember. The subtext is bleak: we don't learn; we reset.
Quote Details
| Topic | Technology |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Recommended Records Quarterly: Interview with Pierre Scha... (Pierre Schaeffer, 1987)
Evidence: It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear power-station to remind us that atomic energy is extraordinarily dangerous. (Pages 4–9 (per bibliographic listings)). This wording appears in an interview conducted in French at Pierre Schaeffer’s home on 2 May 1986 (as indicated on the transcript page), later published as an article in Recommended Records Quarterly magazine, Volume 2, Number 1 (1987). The quote occurs in the interview section where Schaeffer discusses the 'atomic menace.' The online page is a later HTML/OCR transcription, but it explicitly states the original print appearance (Recommended Records Quarterly, vol. 2 no. 1, 1987) and contains the quote verbatim. Other candidates (1) Our Own Devices (Gilles Messier, 2021) compilation98.0% ... Pierre Schaeffer: It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear po... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Schaeffer, Pierre. (2026, February 16). It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear power station to remind us that atomic energy is extraordinarily dangerous. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/its-ridiculous-that-time-and-time-again-we-need-a-101810/
Chicago Style
Schaeffer, Pierre. "It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear power station to remind us that atomic energy is extraordinarily dangerous." FixQuotes. February 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/its-ridiculous-that-time-and-time-again-we-need-a-101810/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"It's ridiculous that time and time again we need a radioactive cloud coming out of a nuclear power station to remind us that atomic energy is extraordinarily dangerous." FixQuotes, 16 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/its-ridiculous-that-time-and-time-again-we-need-a-101810/. Accessed 16 Feb. 2026.



