"It's tempting to say the Ph.D. didn't have an effect, but it's not so. I think whatever resonance I may be able to achieve is in part simply from the amount of reading and learning that I acquired along the way"
About this Quote
Parker’s line gently punctures the romance of the “natural” storyteller. The temptation he names is the audience’s favorite myth: that the real writer emerges fully formed, untouched by institutions, scribbling truth straight from the gut. He doesn’t exactly sneer at that fantasy, but he refuses to flatter it. “It’s tempting” is a small, knowing gesture toward anti-academic swagger, the pose that craft is instinct and education is just bureaucracy. Then he pivots: not so.
What makes the quote work is how he recasts the Ph.D. from credential to accumulation. He doesn’t claim the doctorate bestowed genius; he claims it forced exposure. “Resonance” is the key word: not popularity, not sales, but the ability to make a sentence carry after it’s read. Parker’s subtext is that resonance is built from a crowded internal library - voices, arguments, rhythms, structures - more than from raw experience alone. The authority he’s describing is quiet and secondhand: earned through long contact with other minds.
Context matters because Parker is often read as a master of lean, accessible genre fiction (Spenser novels) - the kind of work people like to imagine comes from street smarts, not seminar rooms. He’s staking a claim that craft can be both muscular and educated, that “reading and learning” aren’t the enemy of immediacy but the engine of it. The line doubles as a defense of intellectual labor without sanctimony: he’s not bragging about the Ph.D.; he’s crediting the hours.
What makes the quote work is how he recasts the Ph.D. from credential to accumulation. He doesn’t claim the doctorate bestowed genius; he claims it forced exposure. “Resonance” is the key word: not popularity, not sales, but the ability to make a sentence carry after it’s read. Parker’s subtext is that resonance is built from a crowded internal library - voices, arguments, rhythms, structures - more than from raw experience alone. The authority he’s describing is quiet and secondhand: earned through long contact with other minds.
Context matters because Parker is often read as a master of lean, accessible genre fiction (Spenser novels) - the kind of work people like to imagine comes from street smarts, not seminar rooms. He’s staking a claim that craft can be both muscular and educated, that “reading and learning” aren’t the enemy of immediacy but the engine of it. The line doubles as a defense of intellectual labor without sanctimony: he’s not bragging about the Ph.D.; he’s crediting the hours.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
