"I've always thought of music as something which gives the words their flight and their wings and the music often comes first, although sometimes I'll have a concept, a title idea, a lyric idea that I want to write and the lyric will come first"
About this Quote
Neil Diamond frames songwriting as a kind of physics: lyrics have weight, but music supplies lift. That image of “flight” and “wings” isn’t just pretty metaphor; it’s a quiet claim about hierarchy. Words matter, sure, but they’re passengers unless melody gives them motion, breath, and inevitability. In an era that often crowns the “confessional” lyric as the ultimate proof of authenticity, Diamond’s emphasis is almost contrarian: the feeling arrives in the sound first, and the meaning catches up.
The subtext is craft-forward, not mystic. He’s demystifying the songwriting “spark” by describing two practical entry points: melody-first (common in pop, where hooks are the architecture) and lyric-first (where a title or concept acts like a north star). By admitting both paths, he positions himself as a working songwriter rather than a poet-in-a-tower. Inspiration is real, but it’s also procedural.
Context matters because Diamond’s catalog lives on big, declarative melodies designed for mass sing-alongs. His songs aren’t diary entries; they’re public rooms. When he says music gives words “wings,” he’s talking about the social life of a song: how a line becomes memorable only when it’s carried by a melody people can hold onto. The intent reads as a defense of pop’s intelligence - not highbrow, not apologetic, just clear-eyed about what makes a song travel.
The subtext is craft-forward, not mystic. He’s demystifying the songwriting “spark” by describing two practical entry points: melody-first (common in pop, where hooks are the architecture) and lyric-first (where a title or concept acts like a north star). By admitting both paths, he positions himself as a working songwriter rather than a poet-in-a-tower. Inspiration is real, but it’s also procedural.
Context matters because Diamond’s catalog lives on big, declarative melodies designed for mass sing-alongs. His songs aren’t diary entries; they’re public rooms. When he says music gives words “wings,” he’s talking about the social life of a song: how a line becomes memorable only when it’s carried by a melody people can hold onto. The intent reads as a defense of pop’s intelligence - not highbrow, not apologetic, just clear-eyed about what makes a song travel.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Neil
Add to List
