"I've been doing these conventions for 20 years, and we used to at least have debates about issues. Nothing is happening basically at this convention, other than speeches"
About this Quote
Twenty years is long enough to watch a political ritual curdle into pure theater. Estrich’s complaint isn’t nostalgia for smoke-filled rooms; it’s an indictment of how a party convention has stopped functioning as a decision-making space and settled into being a content pipeline. The line “we used to at least have debates” sets a low bar on purpose: even messy, factional argument would signal life. “At least” is doing heavy lifting, suggesting the present moment can’t clear even democracy’s minimum viable product.
“Nothing is happening basically” is pointedly blunt, the kind of phrase you use when you want to puncture the official hype without sounding like you’re writing a white paper. Then she lands the real critique: “other than speeches.” Speeches are supposed to be the narrative wrapper around real bargaining and conflict. Here they’re the whole product, implying a convention built for cameras, donors, and message discipline rather than delegates, platforms, or persuasion.
The subtext is about power moving elsewhere: to consultants, super PACs, primaries, and pre-negotiated outcomes. If the nominee and agenda are already locked, the convention becomes a loyalty pageant, designed to minimize unscripted moments. Estrich is also signaling a loss of accountability. Debates force positions into the open and expose internal disagreement; speeches can flatter, unify, and erase complexity.
As a journalist and longtime observer, she’s staking out credibility while voicing a broader media-age anxiety: politics has mistaken performance for process, and everyone in the arena is acting like that’s normal.
“Nothing is happening basically” is pointedly blunt, the kind of phrase you use when you want to puncture the official hype without sounding like you’re writing a white paper. Then she lands the real critique: “other than speeches.” Speeches are supposed to be the narrative wrapper around real bargaining and conflict. Here they’re the whole product, implying a convention built for cameras, donors, and message discipline rather than delegates, platforms, or persuasion.
The subtext is about power moving elsewhere: to consultants, super PACs, primaries, and pre-negotiated outcomes. If the nominee and agenda are already locked, the convention becomes a loyalty pageant, designed to minimize unscripted moments. Estrich is also signaling a loss of accountability. Debates force positions into the open and expose internal disagreement; speeches can flatter, unify, and erase complexity.
As a journalist and longtime observer, she’s staking out credibility while voicing a broader media-age anxiety: politics has mistaken performance for process, and everyone in the arena is acting like that’s normal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|
More Quotes by Susan
Add to List

