"I've been opposed to human cloning from the very beginning"
About this Quote
A line like "I've been opposed to human cloning from the very beginning" isn’t trying to win an argument so much as to end one. Kass frames his position as prior, stable, and non-negotiable: opposition isn’t the result of weighing new evidence, it’s the starting premise. That matters because cloning debates, especially in the late 1990s and early 2000s after Dolly, were pitched as a collision between scientific possibility and moral boundary-setting. Kass’ wording signals which side he thinks should have veto power.
The phrase "from the very beginning" does double work. On the surface it’s a credential: I was there early, I saw this coming, I’m not reacting out of panic. Underneath, it’s a declaration of moral continuity, implying that the technology’s trajectory doesn’t soften the ethical problem; refinement won’t redeem it. It’s also a subtle rebuke to what he and allied bioethicists often cast as the tech world’s amnesia: each new capability arrives asking to be judged on incremental benefits, while the deeper question (what kind of humans we are manufacturing, and why) gets treated as an afterthought.
Context sharpens the intent. Kass wasn’t just an educator in the abstract; he became a prominent public bioethics voice, notably chairing the President’s Council on Bioethics under George W. Bush. In that arena, sounding unwavering is strategic. It reassures policymakers and the public that someone is willing to say "no" without waiting for consensus, and it recasts caution as character rather than hesitation.
The phrase "from the very beginning" does double work. On the surface it’s a credential: I was there early, I saw this coming, I’m not reacting out of panic. Underneath, it’s a declaration of moral continuity, implying that the technology’s trajectory doesn’t soften the ethical problem; refinement won’t redeem it. It’s also a subtle rebuke to what he and allied bioethicists often cast as the tech world’s amnesia: each new capability arrives asking to be judged on incremental benefits, while the deeper question (what kind of humans we are manufacturing, and why) gets treated as an afterthought.
Context sharpens the intent. Kass wasn’t just an educator in the abstract; he became a prominent public bioethics voice, notably chairing the President’s Council on Bioethics under George W. Bush. In that arena, sounding unwavering is strategic. It reassures policymakers and the public that someone is willing to say "no" without waiting for consensus, and it recasts caution as character rather than hesitation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Leon
Add to List



