"I've experienced huge kindness here, a great welcome and some very generous reviews without the snide social edge I often suffer from at home. I'm not patronized here either, which I much appreciate!"
About this Quote
There is a sting tucked inside all that gratitude. Trollope frames her praise of "here" as a report from a kinder country, but the real target is "home" - the social ecosystem that reads not just the work but the writer's class signals, accent, and presumed entitlement. "Snide social edge" is doing heavy lifting: it suggests criticism that masquerades as literary judgment while quietly policing status. The point isn't that reviews can be harsh; it's that they can be mean in a specifically British way, where appraisal doubles as social sorting.
The rhetoric is strategically modest. She doesn't demand better treatment; she catalogs "huge kindness", "welcome", "generous reviews" with the careful politeness of someone who knows how quickly complaint gets punished as self-pity. That understatement is the tell. Her strongest line is the simplest: "I'm not patronized here either". Patronizing is more corrosive than hostility because it infantilizes, turning success into a novelty and craft into a lucky accident. By naming it, Trollope exposes a cultural script: the woman writing accessible, popular novels gets handled as a guilty pleasure rather than a professional.
Context matters: Trollope's work has long sat in that British fault line between "serious" literature and widely read fiction, a category where reviewers often perform their own sophistication by condescending. Her comment reads like an expatriate's relief and a quiet indictment - not of criticism itself, but of criticism as a social performance.
The rhetoric is strategically modest. She doesn't demand better treatment; she catalogs "huge kindness", "welcome", "generous reviews" with the careful politeness of someone who knows how quickly complaint gets punished as self-pity. That understatement is the tell. Her strongest line is the simplest: "I'm not patronized here either". Patronizing is more corrosive than hostility because it infantilizes, turning success into a novelty and craft into a lucky accident. By naming it, Trollope exposes a cultural script: the woman writing accessible, popular novels gets handled as a guilty pleasure rather than a professional.
Context matters: Trollope's work has long sat in that British fault line between "serious" literature and widely read fiction, a category where reviewers often perform their own sophistication by condescending. Her comment reads like an expatriate's relief and a quiet indictment - not of criticism itself, but of criticism as a social performance.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Joanna
Add to List







