"Jackson, however, persevered. He joined the Franklin Debating Society, an institution that had been in existence over fifty years, and had enrolled in its membership some of the ablest men in Virginia"
About this Quote
Perseverance is doing a lot of ideological work here. Hill isn’t merely recounting a résumé line about Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson; he’s laundering raw ambition through the respectable machinery of institutional pedigree. “However” sets up adversity as a given, a narrative speed bump that exists mainly to be cleared. Then comes the cure: the Franklin Debating Society, presented less as a club than as a credentialing altar. In a culture where lineage and polish often outweighed sheer talent, debate offered a socially acceptable pathway for a man who didn’t arrive pre-certified.
The sentence is built like a gate. First, the subject proves moral fiber (“persevered”), then he gains entry to an establishment that’s been around “over fifty years” - longevity standing in for legitimacy. Hill’s most revealing move is the emphasis on who has passed through before: “some of the ablest men in Virginia.” Ability here isn’t tested; it’s inherited by proximity. Jackson’s choice becomes a kind of baptism into Virginia’s meritocratic myth: that excellence is recognized by the right institutions, and that institutions are excellent because excellent men have belonged to them.
Coming from a soldier writing in the postbellum shadow, the subtext tilts toward hagiography. Hill is crafting a usable origin story: Jackson’s later martial authority is retrofitted as early discipline, self-improvement, and acceptance by elite standards. The intent isn’t just to praise Jackson; it’s to reassure readers that greatness, even when born rough, is most authentic when ratified by venerable Southern civic culture.
The sentence is built like a gate. First, the subject proves moral fiber (“persevered”), then he gains entry to an establishment that’s been around “over fifty years” - longevity standing in for legitimacy. Hill’s most revealing move is the emphasis on who has passed through before: “some of the ablest men in Virginia.” Ability here isn’t tested; it’s inherited by proximity. Jackson’s choice becomes a kind of baptism into Virginia’s meritocratic myth: that excellence is recognized by the right institutions, and that institutions are excellent because excellent men have belonged to them.
Coming from a soldier writing in the postbellum shadow, the subtext tilts toward hagiography. Hill is crafting a usable origin story: Jackson’s later martial authority is retrofitted as early discipline, self-improvement, and acceptance by elite standards. The intent isn’t just to praise Jackson; it’s to reassure readers that greatness, even when born rough, is most authentic when ratified by venerable Southern civic culture.
Quote Details
| Topic | Perseverance |
|---|
More Quotes by Daniel
Add to List
