"Jesus claimed He had the power to raise himself from the dead and His followers would be raised from the dead. That's a unique claim in the literature of religion"
About this Quote
McDowell is doing apologetics with a librarian’s posture: catalog the claim, mark it as anomalous, and let the reader feel the force of an outlier. The line isn’t primarily about piety; it’s about classification. By calling resurrection a "unique claim in the literature of religion", he shifts the debate from private belief to comparative religion, from "Does this move me?" to "Does anything else even try to say this?" That move matters because it frames Christianity less as one faith among many and more as a category-breaking proposition that demands a verdict.
The intent is strategic: if the claim is truly singular, then you can’t casually assimilate Jesus into a general roster of moral teachers or enlightened gurus. McDowell’s phrasing also sneaks in a second escalation: not only does Jesus rise, but his followers will, too. That’s a promise of mass participation, not a one-off miracle, and it raises the stakes from a biography to a worldview about history, bodies, and justice.
There’s subtext aimed at modern skepticism. "Claimed" keeps a veneer of restraint, but the sentence quietly dares the reader: either Jesus was right, or the central assertion is fantastical in a way that can’t be softened into metaphor. Contextually, this comes from a late-20th-century evangelical ecosystem preoccupied with evidence, courtroom-style argument, and the idea that Christianity wins by being testable. Uniqueness here isn’t just trivia; it’s a lever meant to pry the reader out of comfortable religious relativism.
The intent is strategic: if the claim is truly singular, then you can’t casually assimilate Jesus into a general roster of moral teachers or enlightened gurus. McDowell’s phrasing also sneaks in a second escalation: not only does Jesus rise, but his followers will, too. That’s a promise of mass participation, not a one-off miracle, and it raises the stakes from a biography to a worldview about history, bodies, and justice.
There’s subtext aimed at modern skepticism. "Claimed" keeps a veneer of restraint, but the sentence quietly dares the reader: either Jesus was right, or the central assertion is fantastical in a way that can’t be softened into metaphor. Contextually, this comes from a late-20th-century evangelical ecosystem preoccupied with evidence, courtroom-style argument, and the idea that Christianity wins by being testable. Uniqueness here isn’t just trivia; it’s a lever meant to pry the reader out of comfortable religious relativism.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Josh
Add to List




