"Joe Smith and Brigham Young laid out Independence, but very soon thereafter enough citizens of the county collected to drive them off, after several stubborn fights"
About this Quote
Violence is doing a lot of quiet administrative work here. Cole Younger’s line treats a campaign of intimidation as if it were a routine civic correction: “enough citizens…collected to drive them off.” The phrasing launders vigilantism into community self-defense, with the passive sheen of respectability. No mob, no pogrom, just “citizens” assembling like a town meeting that happens to come armed.
The context is the mid-19th-century Missouri conflict around early Mormon settlement, when Joseph Smith and Brigham Young’s followers were repeatedly pushed out by neighbors who saw them as political bloc voters, religious outsiders, and economic competitors. Younger is writing from inside a border-state culture that prized local sovereignty and treated coercion as a legitimate tool when the “wrong” people organized too effectively. Independence, Missouri becomes shorthand for contested belonging: who gets to “lay out” a town, and who gets to decide it isn’t theirs to keep?
Subtextually, the sentence is a flex. “Several stubborn fights” minimizes blood and terror while still advertising toughness. It’s the outlaw’s version of plausible deniability: describing collective expulsion as almost regrettable necessity, not persecution. Younger doesn’t moralize; he normalizes.
That matters because the speaker is a criminal whose memoir voice often seeks a veneer of honor. By adopting the language of civic action, he folds his world into the county’s: community and coercion on the same continuum. The intent isn’t to interrogate injustice but to frame displacement as the natural outcome of local consensus, as if history itself simply “collected” and pushed.
The context is the mid-19th-century Missouri conflict around early Mormon settlement, when Joseph Smith and Brigham Young’s followers were repeatedly pushed out by neighbors who saw them as political bloc voters, religious outsiders, and economic competitors. Younger is writing from inside a border-state culture that prized local sovereignty and treated coercion as a legitimate tool when the “wrong” people organized too effectively. Independence, Missouri becomes shorthand for contested belonging: who gets to “lay out” a town, and who gets to decide it isn’t theirs to keep?
Subtextually, the sentence is a flex. “Several stubborn fights” minimizes blood and terror while still advertising toughness. It’s the outlaw’s version of plausible deniability: describing collective expulsion as almost regrettable necessity, not persecution. Younger doesn’t moralize; he normalizes.
That matters because the speaker is a criminal whose memoir voice often seeks a veneer of honor. By adopting the language of civic action, he folds his world into the county’s: community and coercion on the same continuum. The intent isn’t to interrogate injustice but to frame displacement as the natural outcome of local consensus, as if history itself simply “collected” and pushed.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Cole
Add to List