"Judgement comes from experience, and experience comes from bad judgement"
About this Quote
Bolivar’s line has the hard edge of a battlefield truth: wisdom isn’t bestowed, it’s paid for. As a revolutionary leader trying to assemble nations out of collapsing empires, he couldn’t afford the comforting myth that good governance comes preloaded in “great men.” He’s admitting, almost grimly, that competence is forged in the aftermath of mistakes - often public, often costly, sometimes fatal. The genius is that it doesn’t romanticize failure; it treats failure as the tuition of authority.
The subtext is political as much as personal. In a world of brittle institutions, shifting alliances, and civil fractures, “judgement” isn’t moral righteousness; it’s situational intelligence - knowing when to negotiate, when to split a coalition, when to centralize power, when to loosen it. Bolivar’s career was a masterclass in that brutal learning curve: victories followed by reversals, liberation followed by internal dissent, the dream of Gran Colombia followed by fragmentation. The quote reads like an autopsy note for idealism.
Rhetorically, it’s a neat causal loop that inoculates against arrogance. It frames bad judgement not as a disqualifier but as an ingredient, while still preserving the sting of the word “bad.” That tension is the point: leaders will err; what matters is whether they metabolize the error into sharper judgement before the next crisis arrives. It’s less a motivational poster than a warning label on power.
The subtext is political as much as personal. In a world of brittle institutions, shifting alliances, and civil fractures, “judgement” isn’t moral righteousness; it’s situational intelligence - knowing when to negotiate, when to split a coalition, when to centralize power, when to loosen it. Bolivar’s career was a masterclass in that brutal learning curve: victories followed by reversals, liberation followed by internal dissent, the dream of Gran Colombia followed by fragmentation. The quote reads like an autopsy note for idealism.
Rhetorically, it’s a neat causal loop that inoculates against arrogance. It frames bad judgement not as a disqualifier but as an ingredient, while still preserving the sting of the word “bad.” That tension is the point: leaders will err; what matters is whether they metabolize the error into sharper judgement before the next crisis arrives. It’s less a motivational poster than a warning label on power.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning from Mistakes |
|---|
More Quotes by Simon
Add to List





