"Justice should remove the bandage from her eyes long enough to distinguish between the vicious and the unfortunate"
About this Quote
The rhetorical trick is the contrast between "the vicious and the unfortunate". Those words aren’t legal categories; they’re character sketches. Ingersoll smuggles a humanist ethic into a system that prefers clean labels: guilty/innocent, liable/not liable. The subtext is a critique of one-size-fits-all punishment in a period obsessed with order and propriety, when poverty, immigration, alcoholism, and mental illness were often treated as personal failure rather than public reality. He’s pushing against a courtroom culture that could punish desperation as if it were depravity.
"Long enough" is the slyest clause. Justice can put the blindfold back on; he’s not calling for a sentimental bench, just a moment of clarity before the state’s power comes down. It’s an argument for mercy as intelligence, not softness - and for a legal system confident enough to admit that equality without context can become another kind of injustice.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 12 (Dresden Edition) (Robert G. Ingersoll, 1900)
Evidence: The fortunate should assist the victims of accident; the strong should defend the weak, and the intellectual should lead, with loving hands, the mental poor; but justice should remove the bandage from her eyes long enough to distinguish between the vicious and the unfortunate. (Essay: “Prof. Van Buren Denslow’s ‘Modern Thinkers’” (preface)). This sentence appears in Robert G. Ingersoll’s preface titled “PROF. VAN BUREN DENSLOW’S ‘MODERN THINKERS.’” in the Dresden Edition of Ingersoll’s collected works (Volume XII, “Miscellany”). ([infidels.org](https://infidels.org/library/historical/robert-ingersoll-modern-thinkers/)) The same line is also used as an epigraph on the title page of “The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll” Volume X (Legal) in the same Dresden Edition collected-works set. ([gutenberg.org](https://www.gutenberg.org/files/38810/38810-h/38810-h.htm)) However, the epigraph usage does not establish when Ingersoll first wrote/spoke it, only that it was selected as a motto for that volume. IMPORTANT LIMITATION (re: ‘FIRST published/spoken’): I was able to verify the quote in Ingersoll’s own collected works (a primary-source text of Ingersoll’s writings), but I could not, from the accessible sources in this search, determine the earliest *first* appearance in print or speech (e.g., whether it first appeared in an earlier standalone publication, periodical appearance of the preface, or earlier speech). One strong lead is that the quote is embedded in his preface to Denslow’s book “Modern Thinkers,” for which a digitized scan indicates an 1880 publication date for Denslow’s book. ([commons.wikimedia.org](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AModern_thinkers_principally_upon_social_science%3B_what_they_think_and_why%3B_%28IA_modernthinkerspr00densuoft%29.pdf)) But I cannot confirm from the scan itself (within this tool session) the exact page number on which the sentence appears in that 1880 volume, nor can I confirm whether Ingersoll delivered/published it eve... Other candidates (1) The Essential Works of Robert G. Ingersoll (Robert Green Ingersoll, 2023) compilation95.0% Robert Green Ingersoll. only useless, but hurtful. After all, God is but a guess, throned and established by ... Just... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Ingersoll, Robert G. (2026, February 14). Justice should remove the bandage from her eyes long enough to distinguish between the vicious and the unfortunate. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/justice-should-remove-the-bandage-from-her-eyes-90905/
Chicago Style
Ingersoll, Robert G. "Justice should remove the bandage from her eyes long enough to distinguish between the vicious and the unfortunate." FixQuotes. February 14, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/justice-should-remove-the-bandage-from-her-eyes-90905/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Justice should remove the bandage from her eyes long enough to distinguish between the vicious and the unfortunate." FixQuotes, 14 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/justice-should-remove-the-bandage-from-her-eyes-90905/. Accessed 26 Feb. 2026.










