"Keep a watch also on the faults of the patients, which often make them lie about the taking of things prescribed"
About this Quote
Medicine, Hippocrates reminds us, is never just biology; its most stubborn variable is human behavior. The line reads like a clinician’s side-eye across 2,400 years: watch the patient’s “faults” because they’ll swear they followed orders when they didn’t. It’s blunt, even a little accusatory, and that bluntness is the point. Early medicine had limited diagnostics and a lot at stake in observation. If a treatment “failed,” the physician needed a way to sort bad remedy from bad compliance. Hippocrates is building a protocol for uncertainty: don’t only scrutinize the disease, scrutinize the narrative.
The subtext is the fragile economy of trust in the exam room. Patients lie not necessarily from malice, but from embarrassment, fear of judgment, or a desire to please the authority figure who just prescribed something unpleasant. Hippocrates frames this as “faults,” revealing a moral lens typical of ancient thought: noncompliance becomes character, not circumstance. That framing also protects the physician’s status. If the patient didn’t take the medicine, the physician’s theory stays intact; the blame relocates to the unreliable witness.
Context matters: in an era without labs, adherence was invisible, and medical reputations were public currency. The quote anticipates a modern insight, though with less empathy: outcomes depend on what people actually do once they leave the room. It’s an early acknowledgment that the clinical encounter is partly investigative journalism - cross-checking, reading contradictions, and treating the story as data.
The subtext is the fragile economy of trust in the exam room. Patients lie not necessarily from malice, but from embarrassment, fear of judgment, or a desire to please the authority figure who just prescribed something unpleasant. Hippocrates frames this as “faults,” revealing a moral lens typical of ancient thought: noncompliance becomes character, not circumstance. That framing also protects the physician’s status. If the patient didn’t take the medicine, the physician’s theory stays intact; the blame relocates to the unreliable witness.
Context matters: in an era without labs, adherence was invisible, and medical reputations were public currency. The quote anticipates a modern insight, though with less empathy: outcomes depend on what people actually do once they leave the room. It’s an early acknowledgment that the clinical encounter is partly investigative journalism - cross-checking, reading contradictions, and treating the story as data.
Quote Details
| Topic | Doctor |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Hippocrates
Add to List




