"Kennedy did not have to run the risk of having his ideas and his words shortened and adulterated by a correspondent. This was the television era, not only in campaigning, but in holding the presidency"
About this Quote
Sidey is clocking a power shift that looks technical but is really political: television didn’t just broadcast the presidency, it re-engineered it. When he notes that Kennedy no longer had to risk a correspondent “shortening and adulterating” his ideas, he’s describing the collapse of a whole mediation system. The old print-era bargain gave reporters the authority to compress, paraphrase, and inevitably editorialize; the politician had to live with the edit. TV, by contrast, offers the intoxicating promise of uncut presence: the candidate’s face, cadence, and confidence delivered straight into the living room, with fewer gatekeepers and less room for rival narration.
The word “adulterated” does extra work. It’s not just “simplified,” but contaminated, as if journalistic interpretation is a pollutant. Sidey’s subtext is ambivalent: Kennedy’s advantage is also journalism’s loss. What’s gained in authenticity is also a new kind of control, because television doesn’t eliminate editing; it relocates it. The campaign can stage-manage the message, the visuals, the timing, the emotional temperature. If reporters once trimmed the speech, now the medium trims the politics, rewarding telegenic composure over complicated argument.
Context matters: Sidey covered presidents at the exact moment the office became performance-intensive, when “holding the presidency” started to mean maintaining a continuous image, not just governing. His line isn’t nostalgia for ink; it’s a warning that the presidency, once filtered through institutions, is now filtered through optics. And optics, unlike correspondents, rarely ask follow-up questions.
The word “adulterated” does extra work. It’s not just “simplified,” but contaminated, as if journalistic interpretation is a pollutant. Sidey’s subtext is ambivalent: Kennedy’s advantage is also journalism’s loss. What’s gained in authenticity is also a new kind of control, because television doesn’t eliminate editing; it relocates it. The campaign can stage-manage the message, the visuals, the timing, the emotional temperature. If reporters once trimmed the speech, now the medium trims the politics, rewarding telegenic composure over complicated argument.
Context matters: Sidey covered presidents at the exact moment the office became performance-intensive, when “holding the presidency” started to mean maintaining a continuous image, not just governing. His line isn’t nostalgia for ink; it’s a warning that the presidency, once filtered through institutions, is now filtered through optics. And optics, unlike correspondents, rarely ask follow-up questions.
Quote Details
| Topic | Technology |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Hugh
Add to List


